April 29, 2008

Metacafe Founders Ditch, Reportedly Cash Out Their Shares For $5 Million

Erick Schonfeld

21 comments »

arik-czerniak.jpgThe co-founders of once-hot video startup Metacafe, Arik Czerniak (pictured with his nephew son) and Ofer Adler, have left the company and cashed out their shares for $5 million, according to an article in the Israeli paper The Marker (in Hebrew). Czerniak stepped down as CEO in February, 2007, when he was replaced by former Electronic Arts executive Erick Hachenburg, but stayed on the board. Adler was always an adviser and investor, and remains at IncrediMail, another company he co-founded long ago. Now both have severed ties with the Metacafe. An autoreply from Czerniak’s Metacafe email account says:

All,
As of 20.3 I’m no longer using this email.

[Updated with corrections: Due to a prior error in translation from the Hebrew, we reported earlier that both founders together had a 5 percent stake, but each one actually had a 5 percent stake, or 10 percent total). Both Czerniak’s and Adler’s shares together represented only 5 percent each of the company, and had fully vested. Each reportedly received $2.5 million, but their shares were not priced at the company’s most recent round of funding. Rather, the price was based on an earlier valuation of $50 million. The company has raised more than $45 million so far, with a $30 million round as recently as last August. And back in late 2006 it unsuccessfully tried to shop itself around for $200 to $300 million. The article cites conflicts with Hachenburg and the strategic direction of the company. But maybe they just didn’t think anyone would ever buy it.

Metacafe is still one of the top video-sharing sites, with 28 million unique visitors worldwide in March, according to comScore. But it’s growth has been pretty lackluster all year (up 15 percent). Meanwhile, YouTube keeps widening the gap with nearly ten times as many worldwide unique visitors, 288 million, and a faster growth rate (up 78 percent). And in the same period, Veoh’s worldwide uniques have more than tripled to 17.5 million. These numbers do not include embedded videos for either service, but they give a good indication of the overall popularity of each site.

metacafe-vs-youtube-chart.png

  • Sphere It

Trackbacks/Pings (Trackback URL)

  1. Metacafe Founders Cash Out « NewTeeVee
  2. Metacafe Founders Ditch, Reportedly Cash Out Their Shares For $5 Million
  3. TechCrunch Japanese アーカイブ » ファウンダー2人がMetacafe辞任、「持ち株を計$5Mで売却」とイスラエル紙
  4. Roundup: WB returns as a website, XBox 360 prices drop in Asia and more » VentureBeat
  5. Metacafe Founders Cash Out Their Chips | Venture Capital Cafe
  6. Metacafe Founder’s New Startup: Clear Applications

Comments

RSS feed for comments on this post.

  1. Angela Hayden

    is there a recession in this country?

  2. Prashant

    not a good example … he should have stuck …

  3. Harry Wang

    Congrats. Cash out with what you can feasibly get.

    Harry “knows you need to think realistically given what you are working with and where you are at” Wang

  4. Chris

    5% of a clone site is worth 5M ???

    I should move 5 hours north to Palo Alto. Actually I won’t. Web 3.0 is coming.

  5. Jay Neely

    It sounds like despite their founder-status, they were largely removed from positions of responsibility within the company. They were disagreeing with the decisions being made, weren’t meshing well with the new management, and had fully-earned the value of their equity in the company.

    So what’s wrong with them leaving? It seems like it’s better for everyone. If the new management is right about the strategy being implemented, they’ll do better without dissension from the founders. And the founders are now free to put their talents to use on new projects, where they aren’t restrained.

  6. Jay Neely

    Erick, have you e-mailed the Series-C investors for comment? Particularly Benchmark or Accel, who worked with the founders the longest?

  7. Mr. D,

    I was close to the company in the early days so i know…

    Metacafe has a single founder and It’s Mr. Eyal Hertzog.

    Techcrunch got it totally wrong.. Ofer Adler was never employed by the company. He’s an Investor. Arik Czerniak was recruited as a CEO after it was founded. When Mr. Czerniak joined, initial capital was raised and the core technical team was already making progress.

    Re-check your facts.

  8. Ha

    It also looks like he mated with a local native, so he is free to return to his home land with a pocket full of cash and a trophy.

  9. Erick Schonfeld

    Mr D., Hertzog, Czerniak, and Adler are all considered founders of the company:

    http://www.aboutus.org/MetaCafe.com

    “The founders are Arik Czeniak (CEO and Co-Founder), Eyal Herzog (CTO and Co-Founder), and Ofer Adler (Board Member)”

  10. jenkins

    Sounds like this company is going down — fast!

  11. Nick Gonzalez

    Mr. D,

    Check your facts. Yael Hartman (their PR rep) emailed me Arik’s bio when I was covering them. Posted below.

    Arik Czerniak’s bio:

    Arik Cziernak, CEO and founder, Metacafe.com: As CEO of Metacafe.com,
    Arik Czerniak is responsible for creating the world’s largest video
    entertainment destination. Three years ago, Cziernak secured top-tier
    US funding of over $18 million since that time has become the leading
    authority on the viral video phenomenon. His unique filter system puts
    Metacafe.com above and beyond its competitors and makes it the fastest
    growing viral video site on the web, with over 20 million unique
    viewers a month as of June 2006. Cziernak was born and raised in
    Israel, where he served in the Israeli airforce as a captain, fighter
    pilot and instructor. Upon finishing his service, Cziernak joined the
    elite R&D program at the Israel Defense Department, completing a
    unique academic program spanning mathematics, physics, computer
    sciences, chemistry, electronics, politics and research projects based
    in the Hebrew University of Jerusalem.

  12. Nadav

    @4-chris

    HA! metacafe was founded in 2003. youtube was founded in 2005. now whos the clone again?

  13. Michelle Cox

    Hi, Michelle from Metacafe here.

    This matter is, of course, personal and private to the individuals. But we appreciate Arik’s contributions as the founding CEO and Ofer’s early support as an investor. We are glad we came to an amicable parting, with the support of our existing investors, the Metacafe team, and founder and Chief Product Officer Eyal Hertzog.

  14. dave mcclure

    not sure what the exact history is/was, but regardless i’ve met Arik before and he seemed like a relatively smart & pragmatic entrepreneur. guess they may be moving on the next (ad)venture… i wish them both luck.

  15. Jules

    Arik is most definitely a founder, and that’s his nephew, not his son! Arik doesn’t have any children. Get your facts right!

Leave a Reply

Continue the conversation in TechCrunch Forums