April 19, 2008

Deadpool: Red Envelope Files For Bankruptcy

Erick Schonfeld

29 comments »

I can’t say we didn’t see this coming. Quirky online gift catalog site Red Envelope filed for bankruptcy on April 17, according to an SEC filing. Its assets will be purchased by Creative Catalogs in exchange for $5.7 million and the assumption of debt. Red Envelope is also getting a $4.5 million debtor-in-possession line of credit from Creative Catalogs and Granite Creek FlexCap.

Two weeks ago, Wells Fargo terminated Red Envelope’s last credit lifeline, and it started to lay off employees. This could be an early sign that other e-tailing sites may be hit hard by the economic slowdown. Or it could just mean that Red Envelope was poorly managed. Either way, Red Envelope will not emerge from the deadpool.

  • Sphere It

Trackbacks/Pings (Trackback URL)

  1. Payment Fraud
  2. TechCrunch Japanese アーカイブ » Red Envelope、ついに破産手続きに入る
  3. Money Clerks » Cash-rich companies, 2008 Fortune 500 & trillion dollar mortgage bomb - Today in Money - 4/21

Comments

RSS feed for comments on this post.

  1. Asad

    If anything e-tailing will be helped by the economic slowdown, as people will begin to turn to it more for savings.

    There is no gas cost for going to a website, and currently there is no taxes, though that could change. People already turn to the internet to find deals and pricing before they go to brick and morter stores, it seems much more likely now that their transactions will also be completed on the internet.

    Amazon is doing something very smart by offering its Amazon Prime service, which is 79.99 a year and you get free 2 day shipping on all products, and 3.99 for next day. This will help reduce the final barrier to deeper adoption by consumers, which is the cost and delay of shipping.

    I signed up for it myself as a trial membership and I am finding more and more uses for it to send me shaving blades and other small items that most would not look to the internet for. It seems highly likely that this was an issue of mis-management.

  2. Blowski

    Is it just Chapter 11 (as in they can continue trading) because the website is still live and taking orders.

  3. Adam

    Too bad they couldn’t figure it out. I still need help buying gifts…

  4. Jollyjo

    Wow…I guess a nice clean site does not guarantee anything.

  5. Dave Litsky

    Money Talks, BS Walks.

    /story

  6. Dave

    Too bad–I’d occasionally buy gifts there.

  7. HA

    Another one bites the dust in ‘Silly Con Valley”!

  8. Peter

    It’d be cool if we have a quick, structured way to check which commenters were right/wrong about the fate of a particular company. of course, that would require that TC covered them in the first place. same idea as holding stock analysts accountable.

  9. Ryan Waggoner

    @HA

    Let me guess, you work for a big record label…

  10. Sean

    If a tree falls in the woods, and no one in the entire world gives a hoot about said tree… does it matter?

  11. Sami Bay

    RedEnvelope’s failure is an individual case caused by management incompetency, I believe, not reflective of Internet retailing in general which is thriving by most metrics.

    RE has a great brand recognition and is one of the leaders in upscale gift space so, new owners made a good decision to acquire its assets.

  12. Peter Harrington

    How come Red Envelope isn’t in crunchbase?

  13. jose

    Don’t think you can say that it’s is in the deadpool. Seem’s like they try to keep it going.

  14. Son Nguyen

    I can see it coming as well. I bought an item from them awhile ago as a gift and it was nothing special, either in term of service, quality or pricing. They fit into a very small niche with a limited growth. They do have a decent brand equity though.

  15. kevin2640

    I have shopped there several times, and while it is a good upscale gift site, I think their custbase may not be a good one for the product.
    With quality products that can be facsimilied easily and sold tons cheaper on other sites, or in smaller storefronts, they might have done better to expand their inventory to include either some cheaper semi-erotic, and maybe even pure novelty products, it might have helped.

  16. Kevin Horne

    Read the press release carefully. As the guys from Monty Python would say, “Not quite dead yet.”

    “We believe the sale will strengthen the Company and foster a sustained turnaround for RedEnvelope. We expect to proceed quickly with the sale and the related bidding process and that the business will have a significantly improved balance sheet, greater operating flexibility and a path to profitability.”

  17. Kevin Horne

    oops here is the link for RE’s press release

    http://www.shareholder.com/red.....eID=305473

  18. Eileen

    they may continue but they will lose the trust of many of their current customers due to the bankruptcy filing. Also, if you look at the company who is attempting to buy them, Personal Creations, it’s clear that they are a rather lower end gift company and may not want/be able to keep the Red Envelope focus on higher priced and more unique items.

    But I agree that the business is still strong (with some challenges to margins due to economic issues) so it could be that their management was what caused them to crater.

    http://www.personalcreations.com/home.asp

  19. Boomzilla

    Asad: Re: “and currently there is no taxes” - actually a customer of an e-talier will not pay sales taxes only if the vendor does not have a tax nexus in that state. For example, Amazon customers in California don’t pay sales tax on Amazon goods as Amazon does not have offices in California. Amazon customers do pay sales tax in Washington state as Amazon’s HQ is in Seattle.

  20. Vero Pepperrell

    Ironic… They don’t seem to have any relation with Red Letter Days in the UK, but that was a company that truly screwed its customers over, originally owned by a Dragon’s Den investor, Rachel Elnaugh, and was then bought out by two fellow Dragons.

    Total load of bollocks, they left customers and suppliers completely out of pocket - hopefully Red Envelope will have an inkling more respect for their users.

  21. anon

    Don’t you have to be dead to go into deadpool?

  22. Jeff

    They definately had some neat gifts but everything seemed way overpriced. I’ve started ordering some really unique personalized gifts from http://www.PersonalizationMall.com because their prices are much more reasonable.

  23. John

    My take is that Red Envelope was too big, and less responsive to fast market and economic changes. Yet you guys are right, people still need to buy gifts. For gourmet foods, chocolates, etc… I turned to http://www. Savorique.com. What do people do for other categories?

  24. Keith

    I think this is a company that has completely fallen victim to poor leadership. 3 years ago they had items that were mid-range priced and incredibly unique. I read an article a year or two ago that they had started to lose money and they thought the fix would be to carry more expensive items. That would be fine if the items would have been of more value however, they took the same quality of items and jacked up the price which was completely ridiculous. I suppose they thought customer’s wouldn’t notice?! That coupled with their extremely poor selection of fall and Christmas items last year did them in. Too bad it WAS a great company and a fun idea while it lasted…

  25. Kevin

    I like the comment by Eileen #18. The only thing she didn’t know is that the Personal Creations executives know both high end and low end. They ran Hammacher Schlemmer back in the 1990’s and I would say that Hammacher was high end Marketing. An article said that they had an astute group of managers.

  26. Jerry

    I saw the website on Personal Creations and thought that they had much more variety of personalized products then Personalization Mall or Red Envelope. Check it out and see what I mean. http://www.personalcreations.com

Leave a Reply

Continue the conversation in TechCrunch Forums