April 1, 2008

Snap HotShots Tries to Show the Linkgeist of the Web

Erick Schonfeld

18 comments »

hotshots.pngEvery day, Snap collects 15 million links from bloggers and others across the Web that use Snap Shots on their sites. We use Snap Shots on TechCrunch. Hover your mouse over any link, and a preview of that Website will appear in a small new window without leaving the site you are on. If the link is to a video, photo, MP3, map, stock chart, Amazon product, Wikipedia entry, movie profile, Social networking profile, or RSS feed, a customized shot will appear that lets Web surfers watch the video, stream the MP3, or see the map in question. Two million blogs and Websites use Snap Shots, and now Snap is revealing the most popular shots by different category at Snap HotShots.

If Google Zeitgeist is an attempt to tap into our cultural mindset by exposing popular search terms, Snap HotShots is an attempt to show what’s popular based on what bloggers and other people on the Web are linking to. “It’s a distributed Zeitgeist view of what is in the consciousness of the blogs that use Snap Shots,” says Snap CEO Tom McGovern. For each different type of Snap Shot (video, photo, map, music, Web page, rss feed, etc.) the HotShot page shows the three fastest-rising links, the three fastest-dropping, and the three steadiest. These are based on the top 50 Shots in each group. For instance, for the week ended March 22, some of the hottest links were to Barack Obama’s speech on race, Arthur C. Clarke’s Wikipedia profile, and Eliot Spitzer call-girl Ashley Alexandra Duprey’s MySpace page (which seems to no longer be available).

I like the idea behind HotShots. What he have here is the germ of the Web’s linkgeist—what bloggers and others are linking to right now. Techmeme tries to do this for technology blogs, but this is a broader cut that could turn up more surprising trends. But there is also alot more noise to sift through.

HotShots still needs a lot of work. For one thing, it is already April. Showing us what was hot the week of March 22 is kind of pointless. For instance, the Rick Roll video on YouTube is shown to be declining, which is almost certainly no longer the case. The HotShots page should be updated daily, if not hourly for it to become truly useful. Secondly, it would be great to see more of the underlying data. Right now you can only see the nine links per category, not the top 50 on which the data is based. Thirdly, the category which should be the most useful (the PreviewShot that shows straight web page links) is the oddest of the lot. The hottest PreviewShots that week were links to +SOL, a new Russian social networking marketing agency, and Vogate, the “AdSense” of China. These may be interesting, but completely out of context for most American readers. I may or may not care what bloggers are linking to in Russia. Sorting links by geography—maybe U.S. and worldwide at the very least—would be more helpful.

hpotshot-screen-small.png

  • Sphere It

Trackbacks/Pings (Trackback URL)


Comments

RSS feed for comments on this post.

  1. Harry Wang

    What I want to know is: Do the providers of these “hot lists” like Google’s Zeitgeist filter out all the adult oriented search terms before publishing these lists?

    Harry “I think they do” Wang

  2. * Miss Universe

    There is no access the original referrers - but it would be extremely intriguing to discover WHAT SENT those users to those pages that had the snapshots.

    Could this be a result of Digg or Slashdot or Reddit homepages.

    It would appear that techies use Snapshots more than most, so the social bookmarking sites may be playing a greater role than normal.

    Interesting how this SAAS brought Snap from virtual obscurity

  3. Everett

    What #1 said…

  4. jenkins

    Snap.com — they do everything AND nothing. Do they have an actual business model?

  5. chris at trade2save

    They’ve got a good service going here - see they’ve used code ignitor.

    http://www.trade2save.com/blog

  6. Paul Angles, Marketing Director, Snap.com

    Hi, couple of comments:

    1. To the article, Erick’s suggestions are well-put and are under consideration. A new page is in production and will be up very soon.

    2. To #1, Mr. Wang–or is it Harold?–sorry, but we do filter out adult terms. If we created an adult version, would you subscribe? I’m sure Everett (#3) would.

    3. To #2, one of the original referrers can be found under “Sample Page” in each listing. We deliberately don’t chose the biggest when there are multiple referrers. We also don’t have Digg, Slashdot, or Reddit in our network and so those have no direct bearing on our results.

  7. Harry Wang

    @6: I cannot speak for Everett but probably if I saw value. However, I would suspect it would be the same top keyword list over and over give or take the name of the celebrity(s)-of-the-month.

    It would be interesting to see the disparity between the top adult terms and their non-adult term counterparts…especially for the search engine “hot lists”. Most stats I have seen are disparate sources and hard to compare.

    Harry “not a statitician but finds stats intriguing nonetheless” Wang

    (How many spelling errors did I just make?)

  8. Notafool

    Agree that it should be filterable by country. I think they need to aggregate enough data points (unless they have yahoo or google traffic, which I assume is not the case) so the hourly suggestion is not realistic. It looks like good fodder for new posts rather than talking about the same stuff in the current TC / Om Malik / TechXYZ knitting circle. That said, I agree with @7, if they were really gutsy they would include the porn and this would be the rage.

  9. Frank Church

    If they included the adult terms, then I would be here complaining how distasteful it was.

    @Paul Angels, just an FYI:
    When I go to snap, I have to allow javascript to run. No problem. but, unless I use I use snap’s specified method (some link) to enable it, it still won’t work unless I clear cookies and refresh.

  10. Erick Schonfeld

    Sounds like Snap needs a new product: PornShots.:)

  11. Bill

    Other than TechCrunch, are there other reputable sites that use snap shots? I’ve always seen them as kind of spammy.

    I do know that wordpress.com has them enabled by default when you create a hosted blog with them, but how many of those blogs would you be interested in seeing?

  12. Paul Angles, Marketing Director, Snap.com

    Hi, Bill,

    A few sites with Snap Shots:
    NCAA.com
    NYPost.com (sports blogs)
    Information Architects (subway map)
    TrendHunter
    Guy Kawasaki
    Panorama (Major Italian magazine)
    plus WordPress, SixApart, and Xanga.

    We publish in 48 languages and in pretty much every country around the world, covering every conceivable topic. We even power a number of search engines and, yes, Harry, even quite a few porn sites.

  13. steve

    I hate Snap Shots so much… fortunately, the Snap team provides a way to turn them off (a cookie-based setting.)

    http://www.snap.com/snapshots_faq.php#3

  14. Whit

    Agree w/ #13.

    Snap Shots are on par w/ pop under ads, Vista, and spam.

  15. lawrence

    Snap shots float my boat but that page looks crazy hard to see any real trends. I likes that MP3 example… in the post… listening to it now while typing away. Cool.

  16. Sergey Rusak

    I am agree that there are some things Snap should work for. Hotshots should be more dynamic and user friendly. Snap should create option when people are able to find how many Shots specific URL received.
    HotShots should be updated on a daily basis to see what’s hot right now. What about widgets which will alow webmasters to copy HotShots and show them on their websites. I would love to have it in my Wordpress sidebar.
    Moreover, HotShots should be integarated with Snap search and Snap Shots. It would be awesone to see how many shots url reveived in search and website preview.

  17. An Anonymous Coward

    I agree with the people who say they hate the Snap Shots. They are one of the most annoying things since pop ups. How come people who put that crap on their sites don’t realize how annoying it is to their visitors. They really should USE their site sometime, maybe then they might realize.

    People who put Snap Shots on their site are easily impressed andthink they are being clever because they have something other sites don’t have. Well newsflash, people don’t put it on their site becuase they have suffered the annoyance of it on your site.