February 28, 2008

ABC Kicks Off Made-For-Web Video Strategy with “Squeegees.” Maybe It Should Stick To Regular TV.

Erick Schonfeld

32 comments »

squeegees-screen.png

Sometimes you’ve got to wonder what goes through the minds of TV executives. Today, the Disney-ABC Television Group decided to launch its Web video studio, Stage 9 Digital Media, with the debut of “Squeegees” on both YouTube and ABC.com.

Lame doesn’t begin to describe this three-and-half-minute comedy about the hijinks of a window-washing crew. The acting is horrible and the jokes fall flat—drunk, naked window washer (don’t ask) scares kids in a day care class as he dangles outside their window. It is something that ABC, one hopes, would never put on television. So why subject Web audiences to something like this? In another clueless move, ABC has turned off the embedding feature in the YouTube player. I guess it doesn’t want people spreading the show around.

I wouldn’t be so harsh on ABC, except that in the press release announcing the launch of Stage 9 and “Squeegees” there is this quote from Barry Jossen, the “Acadamy Award-winning short-form producer” who is now the general manager of Stage 9:

While the new media space is loaded with UGC, we feel the audience is missing the quality experience found in other forms of exhibition, and we are answering their need. This creative frontier gives us the opportunity to develop new franchises, discover and develop talent and, most importantly, expand the standard of excellence set by our parent company in creating superior episodic programming with great stories and production values.

Superior episodic programming? Please. ABC/Stage 9 has 20 more Web shows in the works, and maybe it will get it right with one of them. But with “Squeegees” it is not putting its best foot forward, and it is certainly not expanding the “standard of excellence.” I’ll take original Web shows like Rocketboom, WallStrip, or Pop17 any day over something half-produced. What ABC fails to understand is that when it comes to Web video, authenticity trumps production values.

There is nothing wrong with going the “quality experience” route, but you can’t go half way. Because it is ABC, people will expect more from any show associated with Stage 9 than from someone filming in their house. If it is going to try to teach the Web how video is really made, then it should have picked a different opening act.

  • Sphere It

Trackbacks/Pings (Trackback URL)

  1. Why Some Ideas Stick and Others Die - A Mindmap Interpretation — Made To Stick Mindmap
  2. make sure your site is law compliant

Comments

RSS feed for comments on this post.

  1. Chris

    don’t watch it?

  2. Anatoly

    Turning off the embedding is hardly clueless, it shows a deep caring approach towards not subjecting other viewers to that content.

  3. Sobriquet

    Authentic, raw, and not overly produced puppet shows. That’s the future.

    SockTube presents the Best Picture Nominees, as sock puppet parodies (Juno, No country, etc.)

    http://youtube.com/socktubepresents

  4. Robin Wauters

    “This video is not available for your country.”

    Say what?

  5. Mike Grunburg

    I actually though it was quite good.

  6. Webomatica

    Too polished - eliminate the squeegee wipe and the credits, and just spend less money altogether.

  7. Tommy Tomertinsensonville

    Whats this “not available for your country” bs ? You mean to say that I have to watch this through a proxy, is it even worth it ?

  8. Jamie Conway

    The jerk store called they are all out of you! I thought it was great! I feel like the same thing would have been written if Apocolypse Now had dropped on the internet. Original story, original jokes, Funny characters, the guy that played AC was a bit too mannish, but overall I thought it was awesome.

  9. Blair

    I laughed very hard at many of the jokes. Sure it’s childish, but those are exactly the types of things people love passing around via email. I commend ABC for giving this series a shot on the internet.

    Shame on this clown for not enjoying it as much as us regular people.

  10. Jamie Conway

    You been served BIOTCH!

  11. Greg Whitescarver

    It’s always easier to give a bad review, isn’t it? You’re missing the larger picture here, which is the significance of a major studio putting money and clout behind an alternative media delivery channel. That bodes well for the ambitious YouTube-er, and probably the future of ‘television’ advertising, which is losing relevance by all accounts.

    p.s. I laughed out loud

  12. Matt

    “teamwork, experience, responsibility” … come on, that gag was pretty funny… sure it’s corny but here’s how I look at it… somewhere between amateur and professional is this group of talent, this a big group… projects like this from big studios give more people the opportunity to be acknowledged. So sure the film isn’t top quality or the graphics aren’t all Maya Studio flashy and polished… but the people working on this stuff are likely happy to be able to quit waiting tables, and i’m sure a future a-lister (don’t say it, you’re not loren feldman and it’s not as funny when you say it, reader) is sure to appear on one of these obscure “professional”-ish productions… it will be used against him or her on The Tonight Show someday.

  13. Shaina

    I watched both episodes and thought they were very funny. I can’t understand why this guy was so upset. I suppose it’s not for everybody, but I agree that it’s cool ABC is taking a chance. I think they may have an internet hit in “Squeegies”.

  14. Stephen R

    Matt - good call. I agree completely.

  15. Jaime

    The show is a little mindless, but I agree with #11. The headline is about a traditional media company putting their money where their mouths have been for years. However, this is TechCrunch, the Silicon Valley, anti-Hollywood jet set. Not that there’s anything wrong with it — it’s just important to understand the source.

  16. jamie conway

    Oh and just found a website with all of their “authentic” videos.
    http://www.handsomedonkey.com

  17. Elizabeth D.

    I thought the show was pretty funny, not for everybody I suppose. I will check it out again and see where it goes. I think the review was a little over-the-top, bordering on obnoxious. what’s wrong with old media trying to adapt to the future?

  18. Thomas

    Rocketboom, WallStrip, Poop 17–are you kidding?? Do these even qualify as shows?

  19. Joe Bob

    WTF??? I think the Handsome Donkey stuff is pretty funny. Have you seen Le Montage?

  20. Karen

    Handsome Donkey is fantastic. Definitely laughed out loud. All of them are adorable. Only wish the video was bigger.

  21. Kristin

    I have to agree with Mr. Schonfeld that this “show” (if you even want to call it that) was just awful! I just watched the first two episodes and declared, “Well, that was a waste of five minutes.” I don’t understand the point of a four minute show to begin with, but why make it just awful?

  22. Gooterhorns

    I liked it. It’s a totally different medium between low-quality UGC and studio and I think it fits in well. It’s also nice to have something that I laugh at and still feel comfortable sending around to my parents or co-workers. They went for clever over crude and I laughed out-loud. Everybody is always so quick to thumbs up/thumbs down but recognize this for what it is, a show that has multiple episodes and a continuing storyline.

  23. Chuck

    these guys are monkeying around. it’s a diversion — and it made me laugh.

  24. Stephen Feiler

    I thought it was pretty good. There’s a good chance this reviewer was raped by window washer as a child, so don’t hold it against him.

  25. Lab2King

    I’m going to have to agree with some of the sentiment echoed in some of the other comments. It’s great that a major network, ABC in this instance, is actually being proactive about the internet instead of reactive. People are definitely interest in watching shows on the internet, but instead of filling your online roster with the same stuff you show on regular tv, why not do some programming for the net.

    Surely it’s a work in progress (i actually thought it was funny, got a few a laughs out of me) but just like regular tv, everything isn’t going to be your cup of tea (i.e. reality television for me). I’m looking forward to seeing more of this line of thinking.

  26. Andrew

    While using the Web as a junkyard for shows too poor for TV is an abuse, we should also remember that many aspects of successful Web video might not always pan out on TV. I think Web video can be looser and less refined than a typical TV program and still pull a strong audience.

  27. techgrl22

    This was a brilliant move on ABC’s part. What better way to introduce a new forum of entertainment to the general public than through an incredibly entertaining, intensely colorful, short-attention span series of movies starring a group of adorable and innately likable young guys?

  28. BillyBob

    Dead on review. I am actually shocked that ABC would pick this up and waste money on advertising it. It was so far from funny that I feel bad for the producers.

  29. David Mackey

    Thats unfortunate.

  30. Comedy Club

    I suppose, that’s not bad.