January 22, 2008

Stealth Job Site NotchUp Makes Companies Pay To Interview You

Erick Schonfeld

124 comments »

notchup-logo.pngThe problem with most job sites is that the people companies really want to hire don’t put their resumes on them because they are happy in their current positions. If you are a star manager, chances are your employer knows it and is treating you well so that you don’t even think about leaving. Who wants to bother looking for a job anyway if you don’t have to? That’s right up there with looking for a new house in terms of time-sinks to avoid.

The folks at NotchUp, a stealth startup based in Los Altos, California launching later this month, have a better idea. Founded by two Peerflix refugees, Jim Ambras and Rob Ellis, NotchUp tries to lure talented-but-complacent workers and managers into its recruitment pool by turning the job search on its head. Instead of desperate out-of-work employees going hat-in-hand to companies begging for a job interview, on NotchUp, the companies have to pay to interview you. This is supposed to bring out those passive job seekers every company really wants to find.

notchup-price.pngThe site lets you set whatever price you like per interview, but also provides a calculator that takes into account your current position, experience, education, and salary to come up with a number. What I like about this approach is that it uses economic incentives to try to bring a better inventory of talent onto the market, just like Zillow does with its “Make Me Move” feature that lets people make unsolicited offers on houses that are not officially on the market. If a company is willing to pay you a few hundred or even a thousand bucks just to interview you, chances are they are pretty serious and it is not going to be a waste of time. It acts as a filter for both the employer and the prospective employee.

According to the site, Google, Yahoo, Facebook, and Powerset are all corporate beta testers using NotchUp for recruitment (well, maybe not Yahoo). NotchUp is still in stealth. The only way to get into the site right now is to be invited by a current user, which is how I learned about it.

Setting up a profile is easy, especially if you already use LinkedIn. NotchUp just imports your LinkedIn profile, you set your price, and you are ready to go. Any friend you refer to the site who gets an interview earns you a 10 percent referral fee. As employers search the site, they can make offers to interview you, which you see in your inbox. You can choose to only get offers from corporations, or from headhunters as well. And you can block recruiters from any particular company (like the one you currently work for) from seeing your profile. The service is free for job seekers, and companies pay NotchUp a fee for each resulting interview.

NotchUp is a really good idea. It turns job hunting into something more people will want to do in a way that makes them feel good about themselves. Even if you don’t get the job, you get paid for your time.

notchup-2-small.png

notchup-3.pngnotchup1.png

  • Sphere It

Trackbacks/Pings (Trackback URL)

  1. Cocoliso
  2. maTVperso.com
  3. CenterNetworks
  4. LatinOcean - Marketing and Web Technologies Applied to Talent Management » Blog Archive » sitewatch: notchup
  5. Anonymous

Comments

RSS feed for comments on this post.

  1. sd

    I will post my resume, then i have COO of yahoo, Director of Google. pay me 3000$ to inverview me. once I get the 3000, “oops, i meant yahoo of smallville and google of sri lanka, i dun think we are good fit. thanks for your 3000$ btw. “

  2. Wondering

    Here’s a thought….will this create an army of would be employees whose sole job will be to get interviewed by all these companies and make a living?
    They could probably avoid this by having companies publish some feedback on an employee….but wait which employee would like this on their profile that they interviewed with 5 companies and got zero to 5 offers?

  3. Bokon Too Koonet

    nice…. time to take on 8 aliases with 8 fake jobs

  4. sd

    @2. won’t work. no company wants to tell the world that they are trying to steal ppl from other companies. and by looking at the ppl they are interviewing, they could leak their corporate secret.

  5. AT

    I could certainly see some issues here already. What type of criteria needs to be met to receive payment? I wonder…. With such incentives, will surely come jobseeker fraud and the potential for a new breed of professional NotchUp Interviewees. Interesting idea, though. May I get an invitation to test?

  6. Dan Ushman

    Clever. But what is stopping people from making a living off simply going to job interviews?

    This is a weird model and I can’t see this actually working out in the long run, to open for abuse, unless they have some good anti-abuse features built in.

  7. Dan Ushman

    I mean Too* open for abuse. Sorry to um yeah im done.

  8. Dave

    #5 - That can easily be taken care of of an escrow service like a lot of freelance website. I’m not a beta tester, but myabe thats what they are doing or hoping for.

  9. Mark

    Isn’t this why companies hire really excellent and focused executive recruiters? To find the people, who aren’t necessarily looking?

    I mean why pay $600 to interview one person, when you can hire a company to find the candidates for you, and where much of the fee structure is geared so you dont pay a lot of money unless you hire one of the candidates they gave you.

  10. Web Tasarım

    This is really cool you know

  11. Dizi

    they can be better

  12. Steve Brewer

    My last two 6 interviews and 2 jobs came from unsolicited interviews. People found my resume somewhere, read my blog, etc and contacted me offering an interview. I have turned down many more opportunities, mainly because it’s time consuming. Count me interested.

  13. Erick Schonfeld

    There is a feedback/reputation system as well that lets employers rate you on how seriously you took the interview. It’s kind of like eBay. Anyone with a bad rating is less likely to get an interview offer in the future.

    But anything can be gamed.

  14. WebSideVentures

    I’m sure they are using some sort of escrow service to withhold payment until certain criteria are met for the interview. What would stop a valuable employee from doing interviews just for the extra cash though?

  15. Jeff the Great

    @Erick

    Want to send an invite my way?

  16. hire wrong people

    some interviewers from different company always ask dumb questions like.
    age, marriage, social status… It’s bunch of waste of time. shaking hands.

    Some people have OCD. They don’t like to shake hand either and not call back.

  17. nada

    I just got in as well. To the people asking what is to stop people from just trying to make a living doing interviews part of your profile is the results / feedback from potential employers about your seriousness, etc. Also the number of interviews, etc. So potential employers can see quickly if you are just a player.

  18. Joel Cheesman

    It’ll be interesting to see the official offering, but I fear this thing could be wrought with tire-kickers hoping to make a quick buck with no real interest of leaving their current job. And employers will cool quickly if positive results aren’t obtained early in the process.

  19. Techcrunch was name after Techcooocks

    One problem what about telemarket. Only f*cks use people resume and send them third party rings. This happens.
    There is such thing is corporate bully.

  20. Nat

    This may work or may not work Idea but interesting concept specially for high profiles individual…

    Nat
    http://www.workersinc.com

  21. Garth

    I would post a comment, but you can’t afford it.

  22. Tino Buntic

    I like the concept. This puts employees in control of the interview.

    Normally, a job seeker going into an interview has to sell himself because he wants the job. This turns the table and requires the employer to sell themselves because they want the candidate.

  23. Jo

    What’s the best way to get an invitation?

  24. Chris

    I don’t think employers are willing to go that far.

    We’re going to be competing with sites like this soon and our idea was to start offline walk-in centers and having a nation wide offline component to building your career where employers and employees can physically meet.
    Nobody in VC wants to venture into the offline world because of the expense, so there’s real room for growth there.

    As for the pay per interview feature as is, I have doubts.

  25. idf

    This is novel, interested to see where this goes.

    http://p2plendingwithprosper.blogspot.com/

  26. Danny Robinson

    As an employer, it’s way cheaper than using recruiter. I can hardly wait until it works in Canada. This idea rocks! And I’m not saying that because Rob and Jim are good friends. Good luck at the Demo Conference next week guys!

  27. Adam Hyman

    Whats the best way to get a beta invite?

    Adamhman AT gmail :)

  28. Andrew

    I see a few problems with this:

    a) How many companies are willing to pay $600 to interview one person?
    b) How do the companies know the person’s resume is legit? Whats stopping someone from writing up bullshit resumes?
    c) Since most profiles will be brand new, chances are that the feedback system will be useless, since people can just make another profile afterwards
    d) Whats stopping someone from going through the process, and then stopping at the last moment? Get your $600 and then say, sorry but I don’t think I’d be interested in something like that
    e) Job sites are all about volume, and since they are new, how do they plan to get a large pool of talented people AND a large pool of companies that are willing to pay up?

  29. ml

    The image/design of the homepage is a direct ripoff of GrandCentral.

  30. Brian Balfour

    Recruiters are insanely expensive especially for executive positions, minimum cost is usually around $50K…..companies and in house recruiters are desperate to find new, cheaper ways to reach quality candidates in these days where job boards like Monster, CareerBuilder, etc are only useful if you want to throw money out the window.

    Great idea….has potential if done right.

  31. Patrick

    Pay to interview people who don’t want to leave their current job. BRILLIANT! And the more they don’t want to leave, the more I pay! MORE BRILLIANT.

  32. Aksel

    Headhunters know where to find me, these guys know where to find the profiles they can ’sell’. If a job description sounds good to me, i don’t think i’m going to tell the headhunter anything like “go to that site and pay … my rate is 500 bucks per hour for a normal interview, and 1000$ for a more complete interview”. lol

  33. Joshua

    Just signed up. No way I could find to see what companies are really looking around, but it was quite easy to import from linked in. It will also try to import you contact list form linked in and email them. It was easy to opt out of that, which I did.

  34. Adam Hyman

    Most people would probably get paid $50 to $100 for an interview.

    I earn 72k a year and I’m very happy at my job, but for $100 I’d go to an interview.

    And if I went, I’d take it VERY seriously.

    If they’re that serious about interviewing me, they might offer me an even better job.

  35. Steel

    I’ve interviewed as many as 15 people for one positiong. I had all their resumes and verifications done before I interviewed any of them. This is an absolute joke in my opinion. How many of you have been one of the ” many” who have interviewed for a position only to find out they were talking to a dozen or so people about the same job ? ROFL.

  36. steve

    this will go down the drain like peerflix…what a joke….good employers always get good talent…no need to bribe them for interview

    notchup is good name for non-profit though :)

  37. johns

    This is ripe for abuse on both sides.

    You know the old story about just interviewing people for free consulting help, right? So this is the problem we face, how would you solve it? Thanks for your time, we’ll be in contact…

    Or better yet, select candidates at your competitors. Maybe scope some intelligence on how the competition is doing, what you don’t like, where you think your company is going wrong? All framed innocently to make you seem really interested. Well worth $100-$200!

  38. Jim

    Another sign the bubble is upon us. Paying people to interview. I would still rather pay someone else to “find” good people because if they show up I know they are somewhat interested, not just looking for $100 or whatever. Stupid.

    When hiring people is that tough we are usually at the top of the market (which is tanking every day FYI). Employment will get tight again and this site is dead.

  39. otipher

    Here is the kicker from their T&C:

    “If You are contacted by a Company on NotchUp and appear for an
    interview at the request of such Company, the Company will be
    responsible for paying Your Interview Fee to You within thirty days of
    such interview. You agree to hold NotchUp harmless for any failure by
    the Company to pay the Interview Fee. The Interview Fee is the sole
    responsibility of the Company. Your sole recourse for non-payment of
    the Interview Fee is to contact the Company”.

  40. CSamarin

    what happened to peerflix to make these guys bolt??? looks like their site is still up and running???

  41. Andrew

    Pretty sharp idea if they can overcome the abuse issue. Erick - please shoot me over an invite. Thanks!!!!

  42. Dave Lambert - Recruiter

    This is a brilliant and revolutionary idea that meets the needs of hiring firms and candidates alike.

    If effectively developed, deployed and managed it could be a big step in traditional recruiting and hiring .

    Comments? Thoughts?

    Dlambert@dwasearch.com

    P.S. I disagree with some of the comments previously posted…

  43. james

    This will not work. If these people who need paying are in such demand, what is wrong with headhunting - paid (normally on success, and done in confidence, not on reputation).

    Who is going to build a reputation on how well they interview? Surely the reputation is whether they are hired or not.

    Ridiculous.

  44. Ron

    These notchup guys are smart - many many many people will be attracted to the idea of getting paid to interview and whether or not any companies are actually willing to PAY you to interview, notchup has in the meantime just built up a huge list of job-seekers AND they’ve effectively mined a good percentage of LinkedIn’s database. They could probably care less if anybody is really getting paid to interview.

  45. Dan Purell

    Recruiting need to be changed. There are no standards, ethical or otherwise. There are too many jobs and not enough talented professionals. There are countless terrible recruiters, recruiting firms and contract recruiters. Job boards are close to pointless. No solution currently on the market for hiring FTE’s is reliable or cost effective.

    All that said, this, NotchUp, is not going to solve anything. This is noise created by a couple of dudes with what seemed to be a good idea when they were stoned or drunk one night.

    I call dead pool in 8 mos.

    Dan

  46. Dan Purell

    by the way….
    IF you sign up they spam your contacts

  47. Chris Russell

    Oh no, the job boards are shaking in their boots!

    Paying for access to a candidate is not something most HR folks are comfortable with. Sounds like a niche market at best.

    http://www.jobboarders.com

  48. johnderby

    If Peerflix was dumb, this is even dumber.

    Why would a hiring manager pay a candidate to interview that candidate?!? “thanks for the $700 dollars, but I don’t think there is a good fit. Good luck to you, I have another meeting now. Ca ching!”

    Too bad Uncov pulled the plug, this would have been a thing of beauty for them to spear.

  49. stone

    this sounds interesting for a few seconds but isn’t really viable for many of the reasons already discussed.

  50. bigfan

    pass the invite on the left hand side.

  51. best mobile software

    interesting idea but not for regular people

  52. Fake Erick Schonfield

    I’m sick of people asking for invites and not leaving their email addresses….please leave your email addresses here so I can also put you on cialis mailing list…..

  53. microsoftie

    No beta invite?

  54. sortie

    I can positively confirm that Google’s HR department is already on-board with NotchUp. Over the past couple months, they have been upping their game trying every angle to find great talent.

  55. Chad

    Please send me an invite.

  56. stacy

    Because it spams your LinkedIn contacts, I have received four NotchUp invites today already. Here’s the invite info for all to use:

    *************

    http://www.notchup.com/beta1/?.....c7268ef72b

    username: launch
    password: interview

    *************

    For the record, this reminds me of the whole sms.ac spam-your-contact-list rig / scam. I’ve been recruiting for 10+ years and I’m just not buying it…

  57. fadi

    Google buys anything that might find them a hire. I don’t see how this would work and scale as a business..
    Listen, just because the concept of recruiting sounds simple, or the barriers to entry are low, doesn’t make the job of recruiting easy. same with real estate - shit, how difficult is it to find me a home I like if you just keep your eyes on the listings dbase against my specs/desired area etc.. and that’s why 90% of the recruiters and real estate agents are useless if you really want to hire the best. (they even beat the normal 80/20 rule..). So much has been tried and so much is being tested now to automate and cut the middle man out. some of these tools work only for massive hiring (or ongoing perpetual hiring of the same profile who has high turn over rate) usually for very large companies who scale by plugging same type of people/employees into very defined roles. But, when it comes to technology workers, specifically sw and hw engineers, here in Silicon Valley, if you really want to hire those who never look at job boards or post their resumes in public domains, the best method is to go to people you know and worked with, or your board knows/worked with, and offer them better challenge for work/growth - money is rarely the winning motivator- to get there, you need to listen and know what -these superstars, top employee- do they really like and what would make sense to them AND you as the employer. the old saying:”know your people”. Here’s the rub; most people’s network of superstars is limited to few, even when you go to second degree relationships, you’re still limited.. therefore your next best option is hiring an experienced recruiter who’s been in the business some time and who’s focused on a the very specific segment you’re in, and has build a network much bigger than yours and your board members’ combined, that can present your opportunity to the best people in the field and the coast for a conversation is often a beer or two.. the cost of such recruiter is priceless!! (:

  58. JP

    Wow,,

    I am curious to see the fine print on how this really works. A++ for revolutionary idea.

  59. Jeff the Great

    and halfway through my signup process, their site goes down. Not a good sign!

    @38 Great find on the Terms and Conditions, very interesting!

  60. andrew

    NotchUp is so stealth…the site is down…I was trying to sign up using the beta password Stacy gave, and it has been down for an hour?!?

    Error:

    Warning: Server shutdown in progress query: SELECT u.*, s.* FROM users u INNER JOIN sessions s ON u.uid = s.uid WHERE s.sid = ‘64ea1959de68fc2438c4db9fad6972a3′ in /home/jambras/public_html/beta1/includes/database.mysql.inc on line 172

    Warning: session_start() [function.session-start]: Cannot send session cache limiter - headers already sent (output started at /home/jambras/public_html/beta1/includes/database.mysql.inc:172) in /home/jambras/public_html/beta1/includes/bootstrap.inc on line 811

    Warning: Can’t connect to local MySQL server through socket ‘/var/lib/mysql/mysql.sock’ (2) query: SELECT data, created, headers, expire FROM cache WHERE cid = ‘variables’ in /home/jambras/public_html/beta1/includes/database.mysql.inc on line 172

  61. Vmoney

    Hey Notchupers, the dot.com bust was 7-8 years ago so your ship has sailed…fun idea, but i don’t know if companies are really going to pay for this…a lot of non-qualified people will join just to get some extra $$$ which will water down the credibility of this…what kinds of assessments are going to occur to really validate what someone is worth?…the real talent will still be out there in “stealth” so those $$$ can be better spent in sourcing or even signon bonuses when you find the right candidate you want to make an offer to.

  62. Scott Yates

    The posters here who are saying this is dumb seem to be forgetting something: Companies right now pay hundreds or thousands to job boards and sometimes tens of thousands to recruiters. Spending a few thousand on some potentially new candidates… sounds like it’s worth a shot if I’m a recruiter.

    The down side is if they are really spamming all the linkedin contacts, talk about a way to piss in your own beer.

  63. Brent

    Is a great idea for times of bubbling growth with a tight labour market, like the last few years. But good luck convincing companies during a recession to pay to find staff when they aren’t growing or in need of employing more staff out of the thousands of highly skilled unemployed.

    Great idea, just might be a few years too late to bubble with the rest. It just seems too dependent on on a labour market trend that is currently reversing. Although this is a doomsday prediction, so we’ll just have to wait and see. ;-)

  64. Jeff the Great

    they are not spamming……you are give the CHOICE to import your LinkedIn contacts and then the CHOICE of which you choose to send an invite to.

    Most likely, those have received 4 invites today have contacts that just select all and hit “send invite.” Same people that take a movie quiz on Facebook and challenge all 500 friends. Same guys that brag about their 2,000+ LinkedIn connections.

    Finally, has everyone forgotten that good companies like Google have already joined? You think the Founders would really start the site if they hadn’t heard “ya, we’d pay?”

    The best candidates are already employed and not on CareerBuilder.

  65. Tech

    Sounds like a good idea. But I wonder if companies will actually pay to interview people.

  66. Doron

    anyone interested in a invite can mail me doronDOTvermaatATgmailDOTcom

  67. khang tran

    money is the wrong incentive to use. it’ll lead to bogus accounts and fraud. i think it should follow a social model instead.

  68. D.J. Capelis

    This thing appears to have hit critical mass over the last 36 hours or so… invites are flying around pretty fast.

  69. johns

    From #39 - “…The Interview Fee is the sole responsibility of the Company. Your sole recourse for non-payment of the Interview Fee is to contact the Company”.

    Seems best to bring a contract with you. Please sign before I’ll talk :)

  70. John

    doubt it will work. good candidate will be more motivated if they are saved hr interview crap.

  71. Liz

    Pretty clever concept. But I wonder if it will become useless fast… What happens when all the “hat in hand” beggars join? Then it’s just another job site.

  72. Tata Nano

    Interesting Concept…

  73. Dennis Howlett

    Nothing about funding so I’m going to take a punt: Mike? $100 they’re in the Deadpool end of year. You game for that one?

  74. kane

    easiest possible way to get an invite? :D

    mercuised at gmail.com

  75. Poker Sharks

    This is quality - You can take a few days holiday from your current job - do a few interviews, get paid and if they offer you a 10k pay rise, move, if not pocket the cash and go back to work.

    This system so wont work - the whole recruitment agency business that is worth billions is built on screening candidates for the jobs available so the company doesnt wastes its time on egits, not the other way around.

    Just imagine if you owned a company and saw a load of your own employees on there advertising themselves out for $200 an interview - id so sack their ass!

  76. Alex M

    This has got to be one of the top STUPID ideas of this year so far.

    Here is how I call it:

    1. They will make a fairly large splash once they fix up their app - seems busted as I can not log in
    2. There will be thousands of “candidates” from countries favored by ScriptLance crowd trying to get some $ and land in the US
    3. They will try hard to keep this site clean but will fail

    I agree - DEAD POOL in 8-9 months!

    Crazy Chickens

  77. Your Uncle Bob

    “talented-but-complacent workers and managers into its recruitment pool by turning the job search on its head.”

    Clue #1: If they are that talented, but complacent then they are probably not that talented or worthwhile having. Do you really want someone that has to be poked and prodded.

    Clue #2: Most employers are not going to pay to interview some slacker.

    Clue #3: The headhunting firms have this area already covered.

    Clue #4: Crap like this may make the Tech Crunch crowd get hot and bothered, but the rest of the world just looks at this stuff and laughs.

  78. atanu

    a non-starter if ever there was one. only question remains is how fast they dead pool.
    i, on the other hand, am open for hire :P will do anything, for anything

  79. atanu

    apparently it has already deadpooled. seems suspended from their host.

  80. Brian

    Gee, I got an invite last night and started to fill out the stuff this morning. Before I know it, I get errors about Drupal not being setup, then, well, the site is suspended while I was in mid-setup of my profile.

    So, either jumpline cut them off for exceeding bandwidth due to getting crunched from this article, my stellar profile crashed them so bad they realized they are no match for me and closed shop, or, yet another startup who can’t pay their bills.

    I personally vote for my second option :)

  81. Max

    I agree with others that this baby is an absolute trainwreck. “What the industry has been doing in the past isn’t working” does not mean that this is the answer. This is a poorly conceived idea that is attempting to legitimize itself by addressing a legitimate problem.

    This whole thing is based on a totally false concept:
    a. Companies benefit from access to a pool of talent that are not actively job seeking. (True)
    b. Only people who aren’t actively seeking will post on NotchUp, and will price-up their interview cost to whatever degree they aren’t looking. (FALSE)
    c. Companies should then be able to interview just the “non-lookers” by using NotchUp. (Appears to be true but is false by virtue of B being false)

    The fact that I am willing to be paid to interview has no bearing whatsoever on whether I am out actively looking. I could be mailing 100 resumes a day and still be on notchup at $1,000. You don’t need an MBA critical thinking class to sniff this out, a high school senior should be able to spot the flawed reasoning structure behind this startup. And you can damn sure bet VCs can. The vast majority of business plans I have read, say 90%, have some kind of reasoning flaw like this that the founder is trying to sweep under by associating the validity of their solution with the legitimacy of the problem is supposedly solves.

  82. Ryan M

    @60: Think you could do SQL injection through session cookies? That’d be a nice trick. The limiting factor would be that their database server is down.

    notchup/beta?sid=123′;drop table users;

  83. Liam

    dumbest
    idea
    ever

    No company is going to pay people to come and interview with them - if they pay to hire talented recruiters, they won’t have an issue getting highly qualified candidates in the door.

  84. Brian

    So, they appear to now be listening on a webserver now. I guess my post about causing them to pack up and go due to my amazing credentials was wrong… It only caused such a surge in traffic that they need a new hosting provider.

    So, any bets on if they have chosen rackspace.com as their new provider? *rotfl*

  85. Eric

    This sounds very interesting. I’d like to try it out. Says they are live in Jan 08 but they are not.

    The premise is flawed though. Non-lookers are far less likely to post and be paid for interviews than someone who is looking.

    For the right kind of person I think a company would pay to interview someone. I know my boss, for example, would be snatched up by Google, eBay or Yahoo in a heartbeat. They have made him good offers and I am sure they spent a lot more money on the time trying to contact him than it would have cost to pay him for an interview. Of course he wouldn’t be on this site or accept money for interviews so I guess this is a bad example.

  86. theregoesdave

    As a Recruiter the concept sounds counter-intuitive and possibly even a bit annoying for companies. While the average person may not interview with anyone and everyone that is willing to pay them, there are some people that will.

    They’re the same people that always leave their resumes on Monster “just in case.” They are much more interested in whoever will give them a raise than actually having to earn one within a company and my eyes roll back into my head every time I have the misfortune of wasting my time talking to them on the phone.

  87. Penny

    This idea is destined to become:

    NotchUp
    …”Opportunists Unite”

  88. Shawn

    I signed up and it seemed pretty interesting — but like some of the other folks above, I’m curious if it is interesting enough to recruiters to make them want to pay for an interview.

  89. Kevin

    I clicked on the link on one invite sent to me and this is what I got.

    NotchUp Will Be Back Soon
    We have moved NotchUp to a new hosting provider due to the unexpected tremendous response to our Beta program. If you are seeing this message the DNS for the new NotchUp hosting facility has not yet propagated to your ISP. Please check back in a few hours. Thank you for your patience.

    They were probably kicked out from their hosting provider.

  90. Bryan Starbuck

    Welcome NotchUp to the recruiting space. Here are a few companies doing interesting work in the recruiting space:

    TalentSpring.com: Ranks resumes by quality. This benefits job seekers because their resume stands out in the areas they are passionate about or have invested in with education or experience. Employers find resumes that match their needs, then those resumes are ranked by quality.

    ItzBig.com: ItzBig has interesting matching technology to bring employers to resumes that match their needs. TalentSpring also has matching technology but with a very different UI.

    NotchUp: Some employers will pay for the ability to interview a candidate

  91. sumit gupta

    good idea. of all the other issues pointed out and rebuffed.. I am sue very soon their database would be full of hundred’s of wanna be interviewees. average joe. then what? Will the HR recruiter scan through hundreds of resumes to decide whom to accept? Thats as bad as monster posting..

  92. sumit gupta

    good idea. of all the other issues pointed out and rebuffed.. I am sure very soon their database would be full of hundred’s of wanna be interviewees. average joe. then what? Will the HR recruiter scan through hundreds of resumes to decide whom to accept? Thats as bad as monster posting..

  93. John Kinsella

    I did bid4geeks what - 8 years ago? Had decent traction and one or two suitors, but that fell through. Monster also tinkered with a bidding thing but gave up on it. Good luck to the 2.0 version of the idea, but I’m just going to put my vote for the deadpool in now…

  94. Ringo

    I just got in. It’s really interesting tool, for both sides (companies/employees), and really easy to set-up (if you’re a LinkedIn user it’s immediate)…
    Unfortunately, I’m form Italy, I suppose it will work only in the US: here no one would pay you for an interview and the direct job-marketplace is still a dream, even if LinkedIn is expanding.
    Moreover, when you edit your profile, you can use only US Zip Code. And you can use only US $, not € or others currencies, but it’s still a beta, so I wait…

  95. Michael Lambie

    invite would be appreciated:
    michael . lambie @ gmail . com

  96. Paul M

    Re. international viability: I live and work in Hong Kong and have received 4 invitations to join in the last 24 hrs (all via Linked-in contacts, and I only have @100 of those)

  97. Maria Cristina

    Absurd. What makes them think that it is the stellar, passive candidates who are going to post their resumes? More expensive candidates are supposed to be the best? How about fake resumes? I would NEVER pay just to interview a candidate. I WOULd gladly pay a headhunter to search + interview + do extensive reference checks + carry out assessments and tests = deliver a trio of the best.

  98. Stefan Menden

    I agree with much of what has been said. They can quickly create a userbase of jobseekers. I am not convinced that a lot of companies are actually paying for interviews. But the main reason for this in my eyes is, that they don#t have to! It is so easy to find peoples linkedin profiles and contact them via linkedin - FOR FREE!

    Any recruiters here? Would like to know what your impressions are.

  99. Sounds good

    I am fairly well known in the field I work at because of a certain FLOSS community I participate in heavily. I am very happy with my current job so it would take a lot from anyone to move me. I totally like this idea and I believe there are many like me — desired but unaccessible. If my time is paid properly I am willing to listen to offers, otherwise the most you can hope for is “no thanks, not now” in an email.

  100. Jay

    Well, I just got a bunch of invites this morning so this must be gaining serious traction with the LinkedIn import feature (checked by default). What was even more fascinating to me was the lineup of companies from contacts that flowed into my inbox as invites. The invite from last week just provided the crushed beta experience but I was actually able to sign in today. However, I did spare my LinkedIn list from blanket solicitation.

  101. Brad K.

    Why would people who are in demand and making a good amount of money want to spend a day interviewing for a few hundred dollars? Especially if they aren’t actually interested in moving. For anyone that’s truly a good candidate, they would rather get paid to get HIRED.

    That’s where PROSUMES.COM comes in. Better business model, in my humble opinion.

    Granted, I helped launch the company but it just makes more sense.

    http://WWW.PROSUMES.COM

  102. Rusty

    I don’t trust anything that doesn’t give me an opt out from all the spam they’re sending me. I’ll just blackhole their domain on our mail server I guess.

    I don’t understand why everyone wants “invites” from this. I’m getting several spams a day from their “users” (apparently, their service imports your existing address book[s] and then spams everyone in it).

    One of those Web2.0 “spam everyone and get popular services”.

    Stupid and lame.

  103. Russ

    I’m floored by the number of people who love/hate the concept but don’t spend a moment of time reading–carefully–the Terms of Service.

    Compare it to Googles TOS/Privacy Policy.

    There’s a couple of points I think are getting over-looked:

    1) You cannot see what your privacy settings might be until you register and agree to the TOS
    2) They’re not responsible for what recruiters / third parties do with your resume or email address
    3) If you cancel your account it’s “marked as deleted” in their database. Not deleted. Marked as such. Got it? Good.
    4) If they sell your information, they’re not responsible for anything that happens to it downstream; the only way you can get off of those mailing lists, etc. is to contact whomever they sell to, and whomever they sell to, and so on and so forth. Plus, those people may all have “cached” versions of your information, so if they get a data snapshot of NU today, you cancel tomorrow and they get a new snapshot and sell it–guess what? Those companies will do a merge to remove duplicates–they’re not going to go out of their way and REMOVE you unless you know how to track them down.

    There’s money in the list they’re generating.

    5) Yep, it’s easy to use that LinkedIn slurp they’ve got set up for you. And, of course, all of your information that is respected and protected at LinkedIn… Well, different set of rules now.

    Pay attention to the TOS and decide if giving up your information is really worth it.

    http://www.userglue.com/blog/2.....vacy-down/

  104. Russ

    Grr. Compare it to LinkedIn’s TOS/Privacy Policy.

  105. Chester Holmes

    The freaking copied the entire Grand Central homepage! Something tells me that this company will crash and burn…especially when you stick all those company logos in the homepage for validation.

  106. Nitin G

    Interesting concept! Can be further extended with features like - candidate rating system (x out of y job offered, x out of y job accepted etc…), certain clauses like - if candidate accepts the offer he/she will give back half or full money he was paid by interviewer so that employer also gets some credit.

  107. asi dizisi

    they can be better

  108. NotchDOWN

    I got an invite and set up a profile. But the site has been so unreliable in the last couple days (server timeouts, Drupal error messages, failure to bring in my LinkedIn profile correctly, etc) that this seems more like an alpha than beta.

  109. Avoid Notchup

    I sent my application to them and they rejected it, I have been working in IT in many IT positions for 16 years and have been told by many recruitment agencies that I have an impressive work history.

    Notchup did not tell me why I failed to make the grade and what they were looking for and where I could improve.

    Their reply:

    Thank you for your application to NotchUp, the premier recruiting website.

    Our network of HR professionals has reviewed your application. While we found your credentials impressive, we unfortunately are unable to offer you membership in NotchUp at this time.

    Please feel free to apply again in the future when you have more gained more experience and/or additional skills ”

    The ‘gained more experience’ was a nice touch - not.

    This is obviously some canned response which makes you feel worse.

    Whats made me mad is that they have my Resume data and I cant log back in to delete my profile - I have no idea what they did with my data and where its stored.

    They allowed me access to login when I submitted my data so I could upload my details and then promptly deleted my account without my approval when I was rejected - with no warning or information in their email to say they did it.

    I think its abit rich that they can suck out data from linkedin and populate their own site (with your permission) - I wonder what Linkedin think about that?

    I would stay away from these guys - I am not at all impressed how they treat people and their data.

    If you treat all people this way, word will spread on the Internet and it wont take long for a backlash!

  110. dump

    this is the dumbest idea in a long time. what retard really thinks a recruiter/company is going to pay for the honor to interview you? trust me - your time is just not that valuable.

    has anyone interviewed and gotten paid thru this site yet? i’ll pay you $1M if this happens.

  111. Kint verbal

    dump, do you have that 1M? otherwise, don’t bet money you don’t have.

    To the others thinking they will be paid to come to interviews and get free money: this is not for everyone. Not anyone will be called and not without a background check. Fake info is useless in this context. Relax you guys, you’re worth what you’re worth now.

  112. FutureMan

    ous ones. Online recruiting agencies like, Monster, HotJobs etc., have worked well in their heyday, but we’re moving forward now. Technological efforts to streamline the process regarding job recruiting and the hiring process are advancing, whether we’re ready to accept it or not.

    Big corporations don’t want to spend big money for low-level talent, as well as high-level talent don’t want to spend countless hours riding the interviewing gerbil wheel. All things being relative, this is just another advancement for us all.

    Q. How many of you would have ever figured you’d be using a personal computer as appose to a typewriter? Or a cell phone instead of a rotary dial telephone?

    Us humans are always resistant to change. It’s in our nature.

  113. Nathan

    This could be a goer!

  114. Sue

    Wow, another way for scam artists to get richer at the expense of “real” job seekers. It’s a good concept but unfortunately companies will be taken advantage of and for those of us who are real job seekers, we are the ones who lose in the long run as this is sure to back fire! I have to agree with a lot of the comments, head hunters are a better way for companies to invest their money to find true “employees”. There are too many virtual worlds existing out there already, this is just another way for someone to reinvent themselves and get rich!

  115. someuser

    I sent the following to Notchup’s tech support:
    ===================================
    I’m a registered member and I’ve been trying more then a few times to import my profile (and contacts) from linkedin.
    It always fail, and I receive the following error:

    * We could not sign in to Linkedin with the below email and password
    * Please check both fields and try again

    I know that the login details are correct because I’m using them to enter Linkedin successfully.
    Is there a problem with the import feature?
    Can you please assist?
    Thanks
    ==============================
    The auto-reply I got from notchup
    ==============================
    We appreciate your support of our beta program. If your message is
    about the LinkedIn import profile/contacts features not working,
    please know that we are working on it and plan to release a new
    version soon. Thank you for your patience.

    If your message is about a different subject, we will respond to you
    as soon as possible.

    Regards,
    NotchUp Customer Support

    ===============================
    Thinking out loud: why did notchup waste my time
    letting me try over and over again to import my Linkedin
    details, knowing it does not work? A simple note on their
    web site will do. This dishonesty right at the beginning is
    not a good sign. They of all should know that people’s
    time is valuable.

  116. M

    Has anyone received an interview offer? Can anyone share about his/her experience?

  117. dizi izle

    thanks

  118. dizi

    Has anyone received an interview offer?

  119. Johnson

    In this fast moving wolrd who will have time to prepare and take an interview if you are not looking for a job change?

    You can not just take an intyerview for fun as you will get a negative feedback which will affect your score…

    I think focusing on active job seekers is important in this market. I recently came accross this website called leapways.com (www.leapways.com). They have some really good interview services. I have contacted them and I was able to schedule an interview with a candidate. Good experience.

    Seems like lot of new services aiming Job and career market these days…

    Keep it up guys!!