December 21, 2007

Mixx Democratizes Categories: Something Digg Should Have

Duncan Riley

44 comments »

In late November I wrote that Digg is still the best online social news voting site online, but upstart Mixx is trying very hard to change this.

Mixx has added groups to their social voting service. The new feature allows for the creation of public groups based on topic area, allowing for free and open categorization of news. For example Mixx users could start a Ron Paul group that only tracks stories about Ron Paul, and Ron Paul fans would then be able to visit this page on Mixx for those links. Digg offers some functionality in this area with friend lists that allows you to track what your friends Digg, but with Mixx, groups are front and center, with popular groups featured on the front page and a link to an index of other groups easily accessible.

“Mixxers” are able to carry on a conversation on the “Soapbox” within each group which is outside of the standard comment areas. Each public group comes with a leader board with daily awards for both the Top Submitter and the “Thought Leader” in that group. And naturally there’s social networking features as well. According to Mixx:

Want to cozy up with other group members (and no, we don’t mean in an “I’m looking for a date” kind of way)? Just browse other Mixxers’ profiles using their avatars.

Group administrators can set a welcome message and create rules for that particular group, and retain control over just how public the group is; Mixx groups can be public or private.

Some groups already functioning on Mixx include Web 2.0 and beyond the terror dome, Best of Flickr, and Cats.

Mixx still has a long way to go in terms of traffic to catch up with Digg, but an impeccable management team, an investment from the LA Times, and innovative features such as what has been announced today certainly help make them a serious competitor in the long term. I’m still a big Digg fan and no doubt many readers will be, but imagine Digg if you could set your own categories. Ubuntu fans would have their own page, although unfortunately the smallest feature or mockup would still make the front page. With a feature like this Digg could even have a page with stories just about Digg, and as we know they are always popular :-)

Loading information about Mixx…

  • Sphere It

Trackbacks/Pings (Trackback URL)

  1. Reddit Adds Ability to Create Your Own “Reddits”: tech product reviews, tech news, daily videos, free downloads, and podcasts, tech, products, computer, mp3 players, cell phones, digital cameras
  2. Reddit announces the ability to create your own reddit site | Social CMS Buzz
  3. Mixx To Cluster Related Stories - Digg Should Have Done This | TechJunkies
  4. Digg Competitor Mixx Takes $2 Million Series B
  5. Mixx’s New Feature Aims To Get Breaking News To Home Page Faster Than Digg : Online media news summary of todays online advertising news
  6. TechCrunch Japanese アーカイブ » Mixxの新機能―新着ニュースをDiggよりずっとすばやくトップページに表示
  7. Newsflash: Digg Admits It’s Rigged and Just a Game | TechConsumer

Comments

RSS feed for comments on this post.

  1. zickr

    I dont know why many tc guys are so excited about mixx. I dont a big fan of digg but for me mixx is just another clone of digg. nothing new nothing exciting.

  2. Dugg

    Mixx is a boring, sad, non-newsworthy clone of Digg.

    If they come up with something truly unique and advanced, I might give them another look.

  3. Laurent

    So it’s pretty much the same as tags? Big deal..

  4. Yako

    Digg must get some good PR firm if they really want to sell. Right now they are crossing a wave of attacks from everywhere.

  5. Binaryday

    Duncan,

    There is a disconnect between people who live on the net and people who use the net for getting things done. The former get excited by cool new features whereas the former gets overwhelmed by the large number of features offered by the sites.

    When I want to read news, I go to digg. I do not want digg to confuse me by allowing me to do social networking and everything else. I have too many other websites that are really good at social networking.

    For those who want both the functionalities at the same place, there are mashups. So if I want news and social networking at one place, I will use digg+facebook.

    This is my own view and not based on any research.

  6. Jason

    “When I want to read news, I go to digg.”

    AAAAAAAAAAAAaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaahhahahahahahah.

    You just made my entire day, thank you BinaryDay.

  7. Duncan Riley

    BinaryDay
    Still…wouldn’t Digg be cooler with this?

  8. Ballmer

    Democracy is not all it’s cracked up to be people!
    ie … Vista is best for you, but most will have to be made to buy it.

    fakesteveballmer.blogspot.com

  9. Technology Slice

    Most of the social bookmarking sites are clones.

  10. Johnti

    I tried mixx for about a month at first it was OK had some good tech stuff, then it started having stuff like the 10 best this and that. So its been taken off my reader. Can someone PLEASE just build a site that has top quality tech articles. When I say QUALITY I mean when something says “10 Linux Tips” you dont click on it to find it say something like …

    1)Did you know if you select “always on top” the terminal will appear above other windows -

    well no shit sherlock.

    Seriously if someone builds something just for us geeks and gets the quality right then It will work. I might just do it myself when I get a minute

    –Johnti–

  11. Duncan Riley

    Johnti
    anyone who uses the phrase “no shit sherlock” automatically wins my vote. Email me with what ever you do that I can support :-)

  12. micfo.com

    The concept looks good- Social bookmarking + Social networking mixed together.

  13. Binaryday

    Duncan

    I agree with you, that digg will be cooler with this. However we need to consider the fact that majority of internet users are not well versed with these featurs. Good proof for that is the article about 63% of US internet users have not even heard of google docs.

    Anyways I am yet to try out Mixx on my own. So I think it will be unfair to comment on it any more.

  14. sage

    How is creating a group in Mixx different, or better, than creating a site in coRank? What Mixx calls “groups”, corank calls “sites”, but in the end it’s all about having different social news areas under the same umbrella.

  15. sage

    Point being made:

    Best of Flickr @ Mixx: http://www.mixx.com/groups/bestofflickr
    Orkut HotOrNot @ coRank: http://vou-naovou.corank.com/

    Same thing, except that in Corank the “group” owner actually “owns” a lot at that space he created, while at Mixx, you’re working for “the man”. Which one would you pick?

  16. mmt

    BinaryDay is right. These sites are getting too complicated for all but the true techies.

  17. Anonymous Cowell

    “Seriously if someone builds something just for us geeks and gets the quality right then it will work.”

    They already have. It’s called http://programming.reddit.com.

  18. Jason

    @16 - Reddit is garbage, just like Digg. Oh sweet, a list of random links, just what I want to sift through!

  19. Devo

    You may want to try CommonGate.com for a different approach to groups and voting + social networking.

  20. nanda

    Popdup.com is a new social media / bookmarking website for video,news,pictures and shopping.. You guys can connect,share your favorites on the web..

    Its really funny…

    You can create groups to organize same kinda buddies and bookmarks..

    Build your own customized page , and share it with your friends…

  21. Mattie

    I can’t visit Mixx because their font is so painfully terrible for reading lots of text. Please become more modern. Steal TC’s fonts or something.

  22. underage gal

    I don’t use both. but i would say good thinking for the mexx management.

  23. underage gal

    btw, cloning isn’t good. we don’t really need three sites of the same thing, then later an aggregation site above it. then again 3 clones of the aggregation sites…

  24. nanda

    http://www.popdup.com

  25. SilentJay74

    Some of the reader who left comment earlier fail to realize a few things.
    You can customize Mixx. Hence the “Your Mixx” section. You can follow technology just like you can in Digg. I was an avid Digg user then moved over to Mixx after Greg Davies got banned. He is a freind of mine so I thought I would check it out. Now I am more active on Mixx then I am at Digg. Don’t get me wrong, I am not bashing Digg, it has it’s strong points. I have found the community at Mixx to be more polite though.
    Also the feature in Mixx have improved it’s functionality and usability. Guess where they got the idea for these features…the users. This is another strong point on Mixx. The founder Chris McGill, and his staff are constantly involved with their users. If you send an e-mail to Mixx feadback, they actually get back to, and not some generic e-mail saying “Thanks for your concern.” You will get an e-mail from a staff member and they thrive on your feedback good or bad. They realize that the site is USER GENERATED CONTENT. This more then I can say for a few other sites.
    As far as the comment “If I want to read news I will go to Digg,” Head over to Mixx and click the NEWS tab. Try it, it works.
    If you would also check out some releases from Kevin Rose he said they are thinking about brining awards to the Digg community. Mixx has been doing that since launch. How long did it take for Digg to get a picture section? Mixx had it at launch. Don’t knock it until you roll up your sleeves, and get in the Mix.

  26. Trae Dorn

    Is it just me, or does anyone else think that news sites where priority is picked by crowds is a relatively bad idea?

    People en masse are generally a stupid lot, and I’m not sure I’d want to read what they’ve picked in the first place. :-p

  27. johnrob

    Anyone want to help me make a mixx clone? We’ll wait until mixx is crowded with a bunch of rude assholes, and then well market this clone as a better version of mixx, without all of the assholes. Techcrunch will pick it up at least 3 times.

  28. Overuse Bubble

    Is TechCrunch invested in Mixx or something? They mention it too many times in relation to the quality of the site. There have been digg clones out there for years that have features like Mixx is just adding now.

  29. aerojad

    Mixx > Digg. True story.

    reddit > everyone else, btw.

  30. DavidEzra

    I’ll be the first to admit that I do not now much about either Ron Paul or those who support him. However, I do have a question about the effectiveness of Mixx in enabling the “Ron Paul Crowd” to get the job done - for whatever job it is that they are trying to get done.

    In other words, you mentioned that Ron Paul supporters would be able to create their own group on Mixx with just Ron Paul stories. And that is where the crux of my question centers.

    Do Ron Paul zealots - or anyone else with a cause - want to (1) preach to the choir and (2) read yet more literature about their pet cause, OR, are they “out on a mission to convert everyone else to their cause?”

    In other words, do creating groups defeat the purpose of what they are trying to accomplish? By creating a group, it automatically “walls them off” from the very people to whom they are trying to reach, which runs counter to why they are expending so much time and effort in making the posts in the first place. It would seem that these individuals make contributions to sites like Digg not so much so that others who share the same view can relish in the new found information, but so that others who do not share the same opinion might be swayed?

  31. nanda

    can you share something about digg vs mixx vs popdup.com ?

  32. JadedTLC

    The problem with Mixx is that it’s design is so old. SodaHead does better than Digg and Mixx, with a dash of widgetry.

  33. azam

    Mixx is going to favor TIME magazine’s content in search results because of their deal. this is the beginning of their end?

  34. JadedTLC

    When will social networks start banding together? I wish that would happen so I could bind all of my logins together.

  35. Steve

    @azam -

    Mixx doesn’t even have a deal with Time magazine. And the deal with LA Times does not mean their search results are favored. Some idiot got that idea by misreading the press release, and it was then debunked.

    Are you just trolling?

  36. Horst

    I also somehow fail the real novelty of this feature. Didn’t for instance Newsvine have this since … well, right when it was started or at least shortly afterwards?

  37. Azam Khan

    Hi,
    sorry about that. I guess I quoted a bad source.

    and no I don’t “troll”. I got better things to do with my life.