November 23, 2007

Manage Those Holiday Gift Cards With Leverage

Erick Schonfeld

37 comments »

leverage-logo.pngHoliday shopping season starts today, but chances are that you are going to end up with a bunch of gift cards this year that you may never end up using. Gift cards are expected to be the most widely-given gift this year, with 69 percent of consumers planning to buy them according to one survey. The annual value of gift cards in the U.S. is estimated to reach $100 billion next year, and about 27 percent of people who get a gift card still have not redeemed it one year later. That came to $8 billion in unredeemed money in 2006.

Gift cards are a big, inefficient business. A new startup called Leverage wants to help you manage all of those gift cards with a service it is launching next week (probably on Thursday). On Leverage, you will be able to register all of your gift cards and keep track of how much you have left or stored on each one. You will also be able to buy gift cards, or swap them with others (like Swapagift). The site will also let you manage all of your loyalty reward programs, such as frequent-flyer or frequent-stay plans. To get people to register cards on the site, it will pay “interest” on the value stored on the cards (3.2 percent for cards bought through the site, and about 1 percent for cards bought elsewhere). Leverage is not really paying interest, since it does not hold the money. It is a marketing gimmick—i.e., the nominal money it will pay out will be treated as a customer acquisition cost.

leverage-target.pngLeverage, which was founded in May 2005 and has raised $2 million in angel funding, plans to make a little money by reselling those gift cards. But its main source of income will be through lead generation and data analytics. Most retailers have no idea who ends up getting their gift cards. As more people sign up for Leverage, it can tell those retailers the demographics of the people who hold their cards in an aggregated, anonymous way. (”We will never reveal personally identifiable information,” promises CEO Mark Edwards Roberts). The real opportunity for Leverage, though, will be in ads targeted at people who already hold a cash incentive to shop at a particular store. For most people, a gift card is really just a coupon—53 percent end up spending more than the amount on the card. Leverage will know who holds cards for which retailers and will be able to send targeted messages to them on behalf of those retailers. But the targeting is transparent. Leverage members will also get to see exactly how they are being targeted—”Male 25-60 ears old, living in CA”.

What’s in it for consumers? They can avoid getting all of those marketing e-mails to their in-box (messages appear only when they log into their Leverage account) and they can control how often they want to receive messages from any particular retailer. And they can have a single dashboard to manage all of those gift cards and loyalty programs. Still, if I can’t even be bothered to put those gift cards in my wallet (I’m one of those 27 percent who let my gift cards languish), I am not going to take the time to enter each one onto a Website. I can see this service being useful if you get a lot of gift cards, and need to keep track of more than five or six. What would make it more appealing is if you got an actual Leverage card that acted as an uber-gift card. You know, One Card to Rule Them All. The way that could work is that the card is tied to your online Leverage account, which knows all your balances. You take it to Best Buy, it taps into the $50 in your gift card account. You take it to Macy’s, and it sees you have $75. The startup is working on just such a card.

giftcard-view.jpggiftcard-exchange.jpgoffersingle.jpgloyalty.jpg

  • Sphere It

Trackbacks/Pings (Trackback URL)

  1. SpoilOn
  2. best buy gift card » Manage Those Holiday Gift Cards With Leverage

Comments

RSS feed for comments on this post.

  1. airj1012

    There is also http://www.certificateswap.com It came out in late 2003 and was in Time Magazine and USA Today.

  2. Mayank Kumar

    A startup for managing gift cards?? They will start a startup on anything nowdays? Is it a sign of coming bubble (Micahel wrote about bubble many days back). Ok, I think that providing stats to retailers is maybe worth doing. But frankly, how many users want to track their gift cards online because it is much more “efficient” or gives them loyalty point?? Of their 3 features listed on site, 2 have “loyalty point” as their selling point.

  3. cedric

    I guess I don’t really understand what’s in it for both users and retailers. I’d think the retailers already know pretty well who’s using their gifts cards. Once redeemed, it can be matched with the items purchased, and often with a credit card payment. And why would they want to target advertising toward someone who’s already a captive customer?

    As for getting a 1% return on my 10$ gift card…

  4. John

    Cedric wonders what is in it for both users and retailers. Here is what I think an answer to that question might be:

    Users: A Montgomery County Office of Consumer Protection report cites a TowerGroup figure that specifies consumers lose nearly $8 billion annually (approx. 10% of gift card sales) due to unredeemed value, expiration, or loss of cards. This is known as “breakage” in the industry, and certainly tools to manage and swap gift card values may help users recover some of this breakage.

    Retailers: I thought the post did a pretty good job explaining this, for example, most people ultimately spending more than the face value when redeeming the card. You could argue they are a captive consumer up to the value of the card, but why not go after more than the value of the card via targeted advertising when the acquisition costs for that customer are now so much lower? Furthermore, they don’t get any of the “extra” purchases, let alone a chance to make a new lifelong customer when the user does not use the card at all.

    While I like the idea behind this site, I would like to see a much more efficient network for trading the value stored in gift cards. For example, I could see competitors offering par value (or perhaps more) for a gift card, but they would need to be able to recover some value from the original card. In a more efficient network that includes, for example, bank gift cards, this could be accomplished by credit card companies settling with a merchant in part by redeeming a merchant’s own gift cards the credit card companies have acquired through such a network.

  5. Jurado

    I made “What Would Jesus Buy?” gift cards….stop insane consumerism and the vendors who reap the unredeemed profits.

  6. rectal colon cancer sign symptom

    How about the breakage on all those cards?

  7. Jebediah Jones

    Do you mean Christmas cards?

  8. UberInvestor.com

    I think it is a good idea. Look at it from retailer’s or adevertiser’s perspective. They can target a consumer based on the type of gift card they manage. For example, someone managing a Home Depot gift card can be targeted for a Home Equity Loan or someone carrying Gap gift card can be targeted for a Shopping Credit Card. The only catch, barriers to entry is very low for this business, but again barriers to entry are low for pretty much every internet / technology business. So it has become all about execution. Great idea though.

  9. salvation army canada

    great concept

  10. =jason

    This is a terrible idea. How many times a year would I possible consider logging on to see how much money I have left on my gift cards? Nor, do I care what potential other gift card holders could offer me in the form of exchange. I think you have to first look at the average amount money given as a gift on a gift card from one person to another. I come from a decently wealthy background and I’ve never recieved a gift card to a store for more than problaly $150 (rare, I’d say average of $50) and recieve no more than one or two per year. So, where is this constant traffic coming from? Are you banking on birthdays? Just Holidays? This is the worst idea I have seen yet. Why is it that $8 billion is unspent every year. Well, let’s see, when people lose their cards, hate the store, or just forget about them in their wallet. If I get a gift card to Best Buy, Im not going to log-on to my dumb website to keep track of how much I was given. I’m gonna go to fucking Best Buy and buy a DVD.

  11. Nonoto

    In Canada, government has recently made it illegal to have expiry dates and handling fees on these cards. I hope for Leverage it doesn’t happen in US as well…

  12. Micro Blog Freie Gedanken Fan

    Nice Site!

  13. DAMN!

    Damn…Erick?!?! What’s with you.

    Can you at least shrink browser *.jpg size smaller?

  14. bhc3

    Blackhawk (Safeway subsidiary) has carved out a good business with gift cards. There is money there for innovative ideas. The Virtual Gift Card offering from Leverage is one decent idea. With Blackhawk, you buy gift cards from a rack in the store, and they are anonymous. With Leverage, you can get them online and have the chance to know exactly who the recipient is. You also can avoid the breakage issue (as the original post notes) and retailers can target you.

    Interesting twist here on the breakage issue. Breakage can be a source of pure margin for the retailers. But the opportunity to market to the consumer directly and grow a relationship with her is a bigger financial benefit ultimately.

    Registration of existing cards is certainly a challenge to Leverage. But since the majority of gift cards are physical tokens, they have to try to get some traction out there. The interest-on-your-balance idea is actually really clever gimmick.

    They’re going to have to watch out for industry leader Blackhawk to set up a competing service. Or Blackhawk will be their exit strategy.

    One other note - the tracking of loyalty programs isn’t a bad concept, but it seems to have had low adoption thus far. Doesn’t Yodlee do something like this? Maybe they can offer some sort of “interest” here.

  15. King Tut

    Didn’t you guys just run an article about Leverage.com?

    Oh no, I’m wrong. It was Mashable (http://mashable.com/2007/11/16/leverage/)…you guys are all starting to look the same.

    My bad.

  16. DONT CLICK HERE

    can you resiste ? DONT CLICK IF YOU CAN ?!

  17. Okinawa

    I don’t think I need to spend anymore for the holidays anyway. :)

  18. ZiZi

    am sorry but this is a terrible idea. so now i have to sign up to a website so i can track my gift cards.
    thats an extra annoying step.

  19. Nice idea...reads like our business plan

    Oh well, and we thought we wouldn’t have any competition. I better just keep my mouth shut.

  20. Philip G.

    Well, GiftCertificates.com has been offering a “Virtual Gift Card” for a long time, but it’s called a SuperCertificate. No tracking, or interest though. They also support hundreds of different stores. Same thing though, send gift certificate by email.

    2.5 years in development? Wow.

  21. Steve Ballmer

    NO!
    Just use MS HolidayCardMaker 2.5b

    http://fakesteveballmer.blogspot.com

  22. Big Tone

    I think a company like Leverage will have trouble with the “One Card to Rule Them All” concept that they say is in the hopper. If I was a Home Depot and selling half a billion dollars worth of gift cards every year with 27% of them going unredeemed, why would I want to participate in a program that would help people keep track of that unredeemed 125 million dollars? That will be an uphill battle for Leverage, IMHO. Sounds like the service is useful for those wanting to manually manage loyalty programs and the such, though.

  23. Ben M

    The kind of people who forget to use their gift cards are the same people that are too lazy to register all that crap on a website. There may be a little value for retailers but none for consumers.

    How about this website: giftcardalarm.com (domain still available for budding web 2.0 entrepreneurs) It sends you an email each month telling you not to forget to use your gift cards. Wait a second, with targeted ads on the site and in the emails, I could be onto something…

  24. 42mb.com

    I think they should design their site with good festive theme to attract consumers.

  25. David Mackey

    Sounds like an okay idea…Though I don’t personally have any problem remembering to spend my gift cards.

  26. Nina Hartley's New Biz

    I like this…i can trade all my Cracker Barrel gift cards for Best Buy ones.

  27. Holiday Gift

    First of all, generic gift cards are boring gifts. Therefore, building a business on such a shakey foundation is bad to begin with. Most people would prefer anything but a gift card for a holiday gift. Secondly, could they not have thought of a better name than leverage. It is an overused cliche from consulting, web 2.0 and a bunch of over done business fads. Bah hum bug

  28. Kathy Aleria

    A new loyalty marketing company huh? Very original…

    I have taken a look at their site, and this seems nothing more than a loyalty marketing play, very much like MyPoints.com. Instead of playing games, taking surveys, purchasing stuff online or offline via mypoints Visa card, Leverage allows one to track their gift card balances and earn some laughable amount of interest. Woah, what a value-add.

    What’s worse is that they have paid a company called launchsquad.com to help with their marketing. This company operates a fake blog, and I mean “Dan Greenberg style”: falling all over themselves with praise after noting some real problem their client addresses (albeit in some minimal manner), and couple that with fake comments.

    I posted a legit response in their comments section and it was never published. The only comment that was published was from an anonymous “ashley” who fell all over herself praising the new service. At the very least, Launchsquad did admit Leverage was their client. Still, a load of crap.

    I guess this is why silicon valley still doesn’t take SoCal seriously as a hotbed for startups, they are just too sleazy. Will they ever learn.

  29. Jason Throckmorton

    Hi Kathy,

    I’m a partner at LaunchSquad, Leverage’s PR firm. The did hire us to do their PR which is why the company is in TechCrunch and a number of other media outlets. I’d say that a good majority of companies that appear in TC work with internal or outside PR support, so I’m not sure why it would be shocking that that they paid us to provide those services.

    As for our blog, I’d hardly call it fake. We in fact have two blogs, one which discusses the latest news and developments at our company and the other which explores stories we find interesting. Some posts include our clients, some don’t. A few, in fact, include companies such as PageFlakes that are represented by agencies we compete with and respect. We’re completely transparent in all our posts that mention clients and are certainly not the first marketing services firm to eat our own dog food and engage in the blogosphere. I would expect nothing less if I were a company in search of a PR agency.

    As for mypoints.com, we’re big fans of the service and wish you guys the best of luck! Our blog administator has been out of the country for the holidays, as soon as he gets back, we’ll be sure to post your comment.

  30. Vince

    I think the site has serious potential. The 27% figure for those who let cards just sit in their wallets will shrink. I’ll bet the net number of gift cards given this holiday season will be an increase over last year - continuing the trend of more people getting more cards. Gift cards may be boring and unimaginative gifts, but they are becoming the standard way to gift.

  31. Julie Broad

    Beautiful concept that will revolutionzie the gift card business. Consumers will finally be able to leverage the power of their gift cards in a fashion that allows them to consolidate, manage, and acquire the things they really want. Looking forward to being a user!

  32. QuitYerBeotching

    Stop being so critical and over-analyzing everything. What Leverage offers sounds like a good deal to me. Hell, I’ll even pay them to manage my gift cards especially this year since I don’t know about you but I am sure that I’ll be getting a bunch of them this year. Having the ability of managing all my cards in one central location and pay nothing for it sounds like a deal to me. My two cents.

  33. QuitYerBeotching

    Read this and you’ll understand why we should thank God for companies like Leverage. Enjoy!

    http://shopping.yahoo.com/arti.....d-pitfalls

  34. Keith

    Try this to manage your own cards. Attach a piece of Scotch Magic Tape, or other brand of tape that can be written on, to the face of the card (not over the magnetic strip read by a card reader). Every time you use the card, write the new remaining balance on the piece of tape. It works for me!

  35. TC regular

    Yes Keith, but that would not work well with the Leverage founder’s (see #32 and #33) business. Who else links to market supporting data on hand?

    As for Mz. Julie Broad, she should remember the interwebs is amazing, and I can see and a Leverage founder both went to school in Athens at the exact same time. “Lookinf forward to being a user”…indeed.

    FYI, launchsquad and leverage folk, we read here enough to see the astroturf a mile away.