May 1, 2007

Digg Surrenders to Mob

Michael Arrington

289 comments »

To say what happened today on Digg was a “user revolt” is an understatement. The Digg team deleted a story that linked to the decryption key for HD DVDs after receiving a take down demand and all hell broke loose. More stories appeared and were deleted, and users posting the stories were suspended.

That just got the Digg community fired up, and soon the entire Digg home page was filled with stories containing the decryption key. The users had taken control of the site, and unless Digg went into wholesale deletion mode and suspended a large portion of their users, there was absolutely nothing they could do to stop it.

Digg CEO Jay Adelson responded on the Digg blog earlier this afternoon but it was clear he did not yet understand the chaos that was coming. The post only added fuel to the fire. Just now, co-founder Kevin Rose posted yet again on the Digg blog, effectively capitulating to the mob’s demands: He says

But now, after seeing hundreds of stories and reading thousands of comments, you’ve made it clear. You’d rather see Digg go down fighting than bow down to a bigger company. We hear you, and effective immediately we won’t delete stories or comments containing the code and will deal with whatever the consequences might be.

If we lose, then what the hell, at least we died trying.

Until today, it seems, even Digg didn’t fully understand the power of its community to determine what is “news.” I think the community made their point crystal clear.

Vive La Revolution.

Earlier coverage on CrunchGear.

  • Sphere It

Trackbacks/Pings (Trackback URL)

  1. Reading up on business... « Hire A Helper
  2. tech.geek » Blog Archive » The Digg “Coup”
  3. The monster of FrankenDigg on hypernarrative.com, a weblog by Wilbert Baan about Art, Media and Technology (v. 3.5)
  4. Användarrevolt på Digg - missa inte | OOZ Webb 2.0 och Teknik - Stefan Svensson
  5. Under African Skies! » Blog Archive » Digg users going crazy
  6. Sean on Life» Blog Archive » Digg Revolt Part II
  7. 5/2/2007 12:12 AM - Matthew Gifford
  8. The Biggest Internet Story of 2007
  9. Digg rikkoo lakia, koska sen kyttjt tahtovat niin » A Heartbreaking Blog of Staggering Genius » Blog Archive
  10. Users turn against Digg: anatomy of a massive online revolt » Ryan Block
  11. Digg-Nutzer revoltieren gegen Zensur durch die Seiten-Betreiber | digital:next
  12. More Power to the People
  13. These Days Labs » Blog Archive » 09F911029D74E35BD84156C5635688C0
  14. Digg surrenders at Iestyn Lloyd
  15. digg surrenders to mob | soggybiscuit
  16. How one hexadecimal string changed the Internet - franticindustries.
  17. Nuclear Sledgehammer » Blog Archive » Internet to AACS: freedom of speech matters
  18. Dialog Box
  19. The TRUE power of Digg
  20. Wings On Some Wheels
  21. Nuudelisoppa » Digg vs. Digg users
  22. Sriram Krishnan™ Live » No diggity
  23. iDigg And What Really Happened With The Industry
  24. Web2.0 will eat itself at Uno se Blog
  25. Vzpoura na lodi Digg - Webtrh Blog
  26. PapaScott — 09-F9-11-02-M-O-U-S-E
  27. Digg Just Buried Itself
  28. Yedda
  29. pot. illegale farbkombinationen « informationcommunication
  30. Digg’s User vs. Film- und Musikindustrie at mrtopf.de
  31. » Digg Surrenders to Mob
  32. Vive La Revolution « Vinu’s Online Cloud
  33. Digg Surrenders to Mob « Official Michael Fomkin Blog
  34. Netsensei » Blog Archive » 09 F9 11 02 9D 74 E3 5B D8 41 56 C5 63 56 88 C0
  35. Ellis Live » Blog Archive » Social Insanity
  36. Thought Balloons » Blog Archive » When a community speaks.
  37. Infomancy » Something about the day…
  38. “when in doubt, do it” » Blog Archive » news?
  39. datter’s unfinished business - » Understanding the Digg.com user revolt
  40. User können beängstigend sein - Digg hat ein Problem » VisualBlog - das VisualOrgasm-Weblog
  41. Kevin Rose Hands Over Digg Control | Marketing Pilgrim
  42. |M|E|T|A|M|i|X| digg.comがmobsと対峙 『Vive La Revolution』
  43. 2.0 Otmičari!!
  44. Drainedge Link Tank · Today’s Links
  45. The Shape of Days: The difference between an uprising and a riot
  46. The power of the online mob wins at Digg. « Technodarwinism
  47. A Look at Social News Sites Coverage of the Digg HD-DVD Incident » 10e20 - Search, Design & Social
  48. i-eclectica.org » Blog Archive » Digg surrenders to community
  49. Donklephant » Blog Archive » 09 F9 11 02 9D 74 E3 5b D8 41 56 C5 63 56 88 C0
  50. Digg community revolts after story is taken down - Lost Remote TV Blog
  51. Kids to digg: you’re not the boss of me at charisma:18
  52. Mindless Ramblings
  53. Tips Dr.com
  54. Startup Meme » Anatomy of the Digg Crisis
  55. Daily Bitekletas » Digg will die trying rather than bow to a bigger company
  56. internet + missions
  57. IndianBytes.com
  58. wfstuff.info » Digg community revolts after story is taken down
  59. The Official Blog of Norflow » UGC New World Order
  60. The Next Will Rogers? Mark Twain? W.C. Fields? - - It’s not random, it’s CHAOS!
  61. Gianluca Biccari’s Blog » Blog Archive » Digg surrenders to Mob
  62. blog.gkaindl.com » The Digg Democracy Disaster
  63. NLC Internet Marketing Blog » Digg Community Revolts
  64. 再談多數暴力 « 小白的窩
  65. Digg Mania 2007: Diggers gone wild! --Stewtopia
  66. DotSauce Domain Magazine » World’s First Virtual Riot Starring Digg.com
  67. DotSauce Domain Magazine » World’s First Virtual Riot - Starring Digg
  68. One By One Media » The New Digg Effect - What This Means For Social Media
  69. When Geeks Revolt: Digg at DieselFueled
  70. The Proper Care And Feeding Of Fools, Internet Edition at Literal Barrage
  71. Digg this: User Controlled Content « c/o operative
  72. Digg Comment of the Day: Kevin Rose is the people’s champion : Tech.Chick.Blog
  73. Handing the keys over to the inmates | WinExtra
  74. e.politics: online advocacy tools & tactics
  75. JDsBlog » Blog Archive » “At Least We Died Trying”
  76. JDsBlog » Blog Archive » “At Least We Died Trying”
  77. Community revolt at Digg at Technology Bites
  78. Digg Burried Themselves - Can They Digg Their Way Out? at Vince Cordic’s Internet Marketing Tactics
  79. Rebelião de usuários histórica na web : Tiago Dória Weblog
  80. Surprise: Digg Moderates Content (and it’s not a surprise)
  81. Vive la revolution at Digg.com « PodTech Network
  82. The Internet is a Giant Brain... « ValueWiki Blog
  83. What if the Internet Mob isn’t right? at GoalieGirl.com
  84. Chip Griffin: Pardon the Disruption
  85. Voodoo Ventures - Idea Fuel Blog : Blog Archive : Digg making news again. Again I don’t get it.
  86. share.websitemagazine.com
  87. Unquiet Desperation » Blog Archive » 09 f9 11 02 9d 74 e3 5b d8 41 56 c5 63 56 88 c0
  88. codepiranha dot org » Blog Archive » Digg the Revolution
  89. links for 2007-05-02 « John’s musing
  90. holotone.net
  91. At Digg, The Inmates Now Run The Asylum - TheVanBlog
  92. NYLON » Archive » Πρώτη εμφάνιση του Kevin Rose μετά την καταιγίδα
  93. ניימן 3.0 » ארכיון » עמית קלינג, האזרח צודרוב והשפנפן וטריקסרין בגדה השמאלית
  94. :: moodless ::
  95. nežinau.lt » Įrašų archyvas » Sunkus ir betikslis cenzorių darbas…
  96. E-Revolution - Digg buried by users (almost) at Entrepreneur 27 Singapore - Web 2.0 Unconferences, Websites & Cool Tech from a Sunny Island at the Equator
  97. El Mike’s Blog » Blog Archive » Digg Rebellion Highlights How The Community Is In Control
  98. Karl’s Weird News » Blog Archive » Mob rule on Digg.com!
  99. Metablogging.gr » Digg: Η ‘εργατική’ πρωτομαγιά των χρηστών
  100. * por acaso » REBELIÃO DE USUÁRIOS NA WEB
  101. The Daniel Gardner Weblog
  102. Vitruvian Mind » You’d better Digg this…
  103. Digg e os número malditos - Mais dos mesmos… at copiar & colar
  104. Aufstand der User bei Digg - Supernature-Forum
  105. UserDriven
  106. Petitpois » Outras faces da revolta no Digg
  107. Digg Rebellion Highlights How The Community Is In Control - MTB - Technology Feed - All About Technology
  108. Venture Itch
  109. PixelThoughts » Back with a vengence
  110. The Power of Community « Izzy Neis
  111. La movida del 09 f9... « TIDDER
  112. The Revolution Will be Digitized at A History Teacher
  113. spinnan » Blog Archive » Viva la revolucion…
  114. tutto è dimostrabile (soprattutto il contrario) Web 3.0 and the pipe-owners «
  115. 09-f9-11-02-9d-74-e3-5b-d8-41-56-c5-63-56-88-c0 | jamesmitchell.co.uk
  116. The Messaging Times :: Blog
  117. ViralVoice.net | Reinvent Your Marketing » Blog Archive Blogs & Community: The Good, the Bad and the Unexpected »
  118. Digg fights for our right to copy « Unjournalism
  119. Notorious Numerals: 13 Famous Numbers That Changed the World
  120. The Voip Blog » Blog Archive » Da Vinci Code Solved! 09-F9-11-02-9D-74-E3-5B-D8-41-56-C5-63-56-88-C0
  121. technologytalk.net » How the AACS Key Sparked a Digg User Revolt | A look at technology's role in modern culture
  122. You Can’t Stop Ron Paul, You Can Only Hope to Contain Him » The Bivings Report
  123. booktwo.org Notebook » Stop Press for May 2nd through May 8th
  124. Digg’s Censoring Continues - CyberKnowledge Blog