September 4, 2006

ComBOTS is easy VOIP and file transfer for your avatars

Marshall Kirkpatrick

24 comments »

ComBOTS is a German company that has just taken its product to beta and appears aimed to carve a chunk out of Skype’s potential customer base. You’ll have to get in line for an account right now but it’s worth an early look at the site. ComBOTS is a Windows based desktop client that facilitates one-to-one communication by VOIP, file transfer, IM and a whole lot of avatars. The service promotes itself as spam-free, drag and drop communication.

Clearly a startup that spent a lot of money on its website prior to launch, there’s something a little too polished for ComBOTS for me. None the less, I think this could be a very viable product for people who regularly communicate with a small number of others online. The interface looks very clean and functional. The company has been in the works for 3 years and was started by a team from the German web portal Web.de.

The service is free to use at first and users are asked to buy a subscription after some period of ongoing use. Subscriptions run between 2 and 3 Euros per month, depending on duration. Users are also encouraged to purchase avatars carrying out a variety of expressions or gestures for about 1 Euro or about $13 USD (10 Euros) for a suite of avatar expressions. The service is ad free.

The company announced on Friday that it has entered into licensing agreements with New Line Cinema for The Lord of the Rings avatars, Paws (Garfield) and United Media, the owners of Peanuts. Look out CyWorld.

Despite their substantial economic potential, I think avatars and emoticon overload are dumb - so let’s look at some of the other functionality here.

The ComBOTS desktop interface is a circle of icons that appear when you hover over a friend’s avatar on your desktop. One of those buttons is for file transfer. When a file is drug into the icon you’re prompted to add comments and then it’s sent. The company says that large files, even hundreds of photos can be sent. No mention of transfer limits, but I’m sure for the casual user being targeted it will probably be sufficient. The system also supports offline delivery of transfered files.

Another button is for VOIP calls, which are apparently free. Making VOIP a loss leader in a strategy to sell avatars and inexpensive subscriptions is interesting.

I like a good smile or frown emoticon as much as the next person, but I expect that the VOIP is going to be the biggest feature here. If it’s as easy to use as the rest of the system I can imagine many people who might be Skype users chosing instead this much simpler tool. Skype is great but it may be overkill if there are only one or two people you regularly use it to communicate with.

Yahoo! Messenger with Voice is another option that could fill these needs, including the apparently important need for avatars. In as much as Yahoo! is understood as a web and email company, however, ComBOTS’ claims of being a closed, spam free system may be more appealing to some people.

I know that many people are banking on systems for closed small group communication in the consumer space and for making tools built on ubiquitous broadband simple for nontechnical users - but I find ComBOTS distastefully patronizing. At least some of the grass roots German blogosphere appears unpleased as well, with Technorati finding headlines like “ComBOTS must die.” I know I’d rather help my family members learn to use Skype and not receive purring Garfield avatars from them when they are in a good mood. None the less, I imagine that a large market for tools like ComBOTS does exist and for many people it may make sense.

Thanks to the fabulous Tim Bonnemann for the heads up on this launch. Sebaastian Wenzel also blogged about this a few days prior and let us know about it prior to the post above.

  • Sphere It

Trackbacks/Pings (Trackback URL)

  1. TechCrunch Japanese アーカイブ » ComBOTSはアバターにとって使いやすいVOIPとファイル転送
  2. ComBOTS startet öffentliche Beta | agenturblog.de
  3. Basic Thinking Blog » Techcrunch über ComBots
  4. Webanalyticsbook.com
  5. ComBOTS Spam Free Communication Service » Dee’s-Planet! Blog
  6. Svizzer Blog
  7. Was internationale Blogs über deutsche Web-2.0-Dienste schreiben » Beitrag » zweinull.cc

Comments

RSS feed for comments on this post.

  1. Skip Trace

    I am currently a fan of Skype, but this is worth taking a look at. Thanks.

  2. NeoTechie

    Web 2.0 loves competition. VOIP will change the way we communicate forever. We have to welcome new companies that try to make web apps better. As consumers, we have to welcome companies giving us trial periods of their products. We are currently in Web 2.0 because the net community embraced change. Let’s be open-minded when it comes to new approaches to current web apps. Remember when companies compete, customers benefit.

  3. Garry

    Totally awesome to see this company come into play. VOIP is a technology that will be growing very rapidly in the very near future, totally changing how we traditionally have communicated before.

  4. Timo

    this company is not a startup. they are listed on the stock exchange since 2000, they are a spin-off of early entrpreneur web.de AG which was acquired by United Internet, THE major internet company in Germany. The offering may be interesting and it is important to know that they have had a previous offering of similar functionality. No big news here. One other thing to mention is that while you can easily signup and pay, it is hard to get out of contracts. They used to only accept signed letters (snail mail).

  5. lordtime

    yes i registerd from Win 2003 Server and god thatthey are comptible with XP

    what a bullshit!

  6. Heiko Hebig

    > this company is not a startup.

    Adding to that, it’s important to note that ComBots AG sold Web.de to United Internet for ~ 516 mil Euro (208 mil in cash, 308 mil in United Internet Stock) and according to some German news reports has so far invested ~ 35 million Euro in the development of their new platform.

  7. Uzi Josephson

    What’s the problem with purring Garfield avatars?

  8. Nicole Simon

    One should also note that web.de is not only a directory but also one of the two leading german speaking free email providers with a lot of ties into different channels of usage (dsl offers included through UI)

    It is not as if they need to get new users, they just need to get a part of their user base to switch and try it.

    While Yahoo does have a german page, it is still considered to be a US company. Web.de also has a working german local search.

    Just because Yahoo is big does not mean they get everything right on this language based market - big american players tend to have more or less a kind of sales offices here. Same with MS - there is no way you can compare what is happening in Redmond with what it is like in Germany. That would be like comparing the valley to a little town in the midwest.

    And I love Garfield. :)

  9. Nicole Simon

    hrmpf they only want to provide information to “real journalists” so be it.

    It is the second most visited portal in Germany. The user numbers per month for the whole website is 11,5 million users, that includes probably all their “magazines” (as they call the portal pages), free mail and all other services like search.

    This is what I meant with “they just need to activate their userbase”

  10. Jojo

    Only to repeat that. Web.de is now part of United Internet. Combots sold it. But I believe they will try to advertise their new product in cooperation with United Internet. And that would be an interesting alliance, because “selling” is the number one skill of United Internet.

  11. Chris

    Interesting concept though. You start with the person (or avatar), then choose the communications service that’s appropriate. To your last point Michael, look at QQ in China.

  12. Sebastian

    Thanks for my name and the comment in the post. You guys are just funny and the success of this blog is well deserved :-)

  13. Jennifer Fader

    Thank you for the voice of reason regarding too-fluffy avatarism (hello, yahoo messenger anyone?)

  14. Remo Uherek

    It is also worth to note that ComBOTS AG has 450 Mio EUR current assets. It will take a while to burn this cash :-).

  15. Pierre Kerchner

    the fine difference:

    skype is p2p

    Combots is using huge servers.

    The benefit:

    I can send films …. ähhh large files with maximum upload and asynchrously.

    There are other gadgets like yousendit.com but here is no autoresume or drag and drop.

    Currently Combots is way too CPU and RAM hungry (100 mbyte and 70 % load)

    We will see, if they get the turn

    pierre
    http://kerchner.de/blog

  16. David Linsin

    http://www.techcrunch.com/2006.....trackback/

    After installing and checking out ComBOTS for a while today, I must say it kinda sucks. Okay it’s still in “Beta”, but it hasn’t improved since I’ve seen it for the first time. It still takes up 90 MB of my memory which is just too much compared to Google Talk which only consumes 20 MB.

    After searching the blogsphere for opinions on ComBOTS I only found blog postings about uninstalling the software. I haven’t found any positive review except for a posting over at techrunch.

    I’ll still keep it installed to check it out more, but if it keeps up using so much memory I’ll probably uninstall it too - at least now I know how to do it thanks to this posting by Oliver Gassner.

  17. Paul

    Hi,

    You might be interested in checking out another messaging service with cool 3D avatars at http://www.orooni.com

    Paul