May 19, 2006

Europe Shows Its Stuff: Innovate 2006

Michael Arrington

44 comments »

Dozens of (mostly) European companies showcased their new consumer web applications at Innovate 2006 in Zaragoza, Spain this week. As usual with conferences like these, the companies were young, rough and hungry. And I see a lot of potential with at least a few of them. I’ve summarized my favorites below and look forward to profiling these individually.

Also, I’ve taken a few days to hang out in London with entrepreneurs. If you are here, we are having an open event on Monday, May 22. Details are here.

The prevailing topic of conversation at the conference was “Can Europe become more like silicon valley?”. I’m not an expert on this topic, although I’ve lived in London and Copenhagen and have spent a lot of time in Europe over the last few years. But I do have a number of observations. These are generalities, and some of them are applicable to certain geographic areas. The UK, for example, seems to be doing better than the other European countries when it comes to encouraging startups. And a lot of cool stuff is coming out of France even though starting and running a company there is, to say the least, daunting.

First, entrepreneurs in Europe are not revered in the same way as the U.S. Many people in Europe consider entrepreneurs to be greedy and arrogant, trying to reach above themselves. That has to change. Entrepreneurs tend to ignore risk/reward ratios, drive economic growth, bring new jobs to a country. They should be encouraged, not socially chastised

Second, the complexity of creating a corprate entity, hiring employees and raising capital needs to be reduced. It’s simply too hard to create a company and get started.

Third, taxes must come down, or entrepreneurs will continue to flee to the US and elsewhere.

So back to the main reason for this post…here are my favorite companies from the Innovate 2006 conference:

ReadSpeaker

ReadSpeaker is a Spanish company. They provide websites with a plugin that creates a “say it” button on the site. Press the button and the page is read to the reader. Highlight text before pressing the button and just that text is read. Lots of supported languages to choose from.

vPod.tv

vPod.tv is headquarted in Paris and Madrid that is yet another video sharing site. I’ll be writing more about them later today, but there is something realy special here. They have a fantastic monetization product, and they are doing things with Flash that I haven’t seen anywhere else. vPod.tv is a company we’ll be hearing a lot more about in the near future. Founder Rodrigo Sepulveda Schulz snagged me after a couple of cocktails at the end of the conference and recorded a videocast here where we discuss the new TechCrunch design, among other things.

Feeds 2.0

feeds2.0 is a Greek company that has created a new feed reader with a personalization feature. It is currently in private beta. Read my profile of them here.

Allpeers

I’ve written about Prague-based AllPeers, the upcoming firefox plugin that allows users to create private p2p networks, often. It’s coming, really really soon. See my profiles here and here.

Wakoo

Wakoo is a Paris-based company that is going to offer a web chat product for blogs and other websites. It’s pretty slick. Compare it to Mobber, 3Bubbles and Gabbly. This is an unproven market, and there are lots of competitors. The Wakoo site is in French, which will make it impossible for them to enter the U.S. market, but gives them a clear advantage with French bloggers and other French websites.

Digislide

Australia-based Digislide isn’t a web application, but I loved watching their presentation. They’ve created a tiny projector (for power point, movies, whatever) that can be built into a cell phone or laptop computer. They are signing licensing deals now and expect to see it in consumer electronics products soon. It’s tiny, silent and totally cool.

Clicmobile

Clicmobile, headquartered in Paris, is Myspace on your phone. I saw a demo of their mobile social network and came away impressed. No idea if this stuff will work in the American mobile market, but I can see both social and enterprise applications for this. Currently in beta.

Feefo

Feefo, based in the UK, is an open feedback forum that allows buyers to leave feedback on sellers, and for that feedback to be included on the seller’s site via an API. I don’t think they’ve nailed the product like Rapleaf has (for example, a seller has to join before feedback can be left), but I like the space.

Violet

Violet, based in Paris, has created a consumer gadget called Nabaztag, a plastic, 23-cm-tall white rabbit with a constant wi-fi connection. The device provides vital daily information like traffic reports and the weather. It also moves its ears around and has these fascinating blinking lights. I want one.

Netvibes

Tariq Krim, the founder of Netvibes, was at the conference demo’ing his product, and he also participated on a panel that I moderated. It’s an ajax home page that is distancing itself from the crowd. My original profile on Netvibes is here. He was definitely the toast of the conference.

Update: Cathy Brooks interviewed me for a two part podcast just after my session at Innovate. You can listen to them here.

  • Sphere It

Trackbacks/Pings (Trackback URL)

  1. VC Ratings
  2. Tech Kix » Blog Archive » European startups to claim some of the spotlight?
  3. TechCrunch » Blog Archive » vpod.tv Raises $5.1 Million: First Look
  4. Peer Pressure
  5. itnorthwest.org » Web2.0 in Europe…
  6. e-Fuze mobile » Innovate! 2006 Summary
  7. BiZwiKi.CN - 喧闹 PK 噪音 » Blog Archive » flickr进入Gammer时代
  8. nonsmokingarea.com
  9. VoIPblog.it » Web 2.0: non c’è solo Silicon Valley!
  10. Artichoke Conspiracy » Blog Archive » Innovate 2006
  11. Dee’s-Planet! » Europe Shows Its Stuff: Innovate 2006
  12. TV Wonder VE
  13. nonsmokingarea.com
  14. TechCrunch » Blog Archive » Conference Discounts: Supernova and The Next Web
  15. Conference Discounts: Supernova and The Next Web - davecentral Planet David Central & Dave Central Planet
  16. robert denton - a day » Blog Archive »
  17. CrunchNotes » Supernova Connected Innovators Program
  18. TechCrunch » Blog Archive » The Supernova 12

Comments

RSS feed for comments on this post.

  1. Otis

    Wow, that is a large percentage of French, Paris-based companies! Vive la France! ;)
    No wonder French is in top 3-4 languages people use to access Simpy!

  2. bounder

    Nabaztag (the wi-fi rabbit) is definately one to look out for - I’ve had one for about a year in the UK (it is the Fench version and speaks French) and I’ve never been so impressed with a gadget. It’s now starting to do some great things with podcasts and RSS.

  3. JW

    ReadSpeaker is definitely something to look out for, lots of languages are supported, and the voice is really high quality. When reading long texts, I sometimes use Opera’s built-in read function, and compared to that ReadSpeaker is unbelievable!

  4. Mike

    I could not agree more with your comment:

    “Third, taxes must come down, or entrepreneurs will continue to flee to the US and elsewhere.”

    I myself am from Germany and left for the US 15 years ago and have now moved to Malaysia to start my internet business. Here in Malaysia we were granted MSC status, which means that we don’t have to pay any income taxes for the next 10 years. The only downside is that it makes networking and getting the name of our sites (such as http://www.blinklist.com) out a bit harder.

  5. Vladimir Orlt

    I’m not sure that I’d encourage (whether this implies $ of not) someone who tends to ignore risk/reward ratios.

  6. Michael Arrington

    Vladimir - well, most entrepreneurs fail, so what i mean is that they get utility out of starting their own company. Society as a whole benefits, if there is an efficient mechanism for moving capital and other resources to the startups most likely to succeed.

  7. Otis

    Michael:
    I agree with your comments about Europe and conditions for startups there. But there is another thing that can be added: a lot of passionate entrepreneurs are _already_ gone! Major brain drain. So, who’s left? Not people who understand entrepreneurs and what they need. Thus, it will take generations of hard, concious effort for this to be reverted. On the other hand, life in Europe tends to be more humane. Slower. More vacation. Work is not #1 thing in life. And a big part of that, in my opinion, is that all the workoholics are slaving away on the other side of the pond.
    Ok, enough chatting. back to work!

  8. Dimitar Vesselinov

    In the meantime, the IPO market in Europe is hot.

    “The numbers show just how dramatic the move has been. Of the top 25 global IPOs in 2005, only one took place in the U.S.; back in 2000, 9 of the top 10 were listed on American soil. Equally telling, between 1996 and 2001 the NYSE averaged 50 non-U.S. listings annually; in 2005, it gained just eight. Meanwhile, the London Stock Exchange drew 139 new foreign companies in 2005.”

    “London is attracting wee companies, too. Its fast-growing Alternative Investment Market (AIM) is rapidly becoming the location of choice for startups from Europe, Israel, and across the globe. AIM has even attracted 35 U.S. companies, including 19 last year.”
    http://www.businessweek.com/ma.....+top+story

  9. jbelkin

    most of the comments above are true and of course, there are generalizations but it is a business cultural difference. Here in silicon valley, failure is not really considered a problem - as long as what you didn’t rip off your investors, it’s fine to fail - you just try again. And along with that, it means investors (large & small, casual & formal) are willing to shot with you because they know the odds are against you but another Google (12 figure market caps) might be around the corner. The attitude is different. Let’s give it our best shot and if not, so be it. Europe had that attitude a few hundred years ago but that sense of urgency is mostly gone - it’s telling what a Dutch person told me a few years ago - that they had an idea to test out (I won’t reveal the details) but was essentially told, that doesn’t sound plausible, you’ll most likely fail so why try? While here in silicon valley, even if it’s remote and the payoff seems huge, why not try it - if you fail - at least we learned that’s not the right path … that’s the main difference. And yes, my Dutch friend is here in the US … part of the brain & attitude drain … America is not really a place but a state of mind. I think related to that is the sense you can re-invent yourself in America, especially in California - no one really cares what village you came from, what your parents did, how you did in school or what school you went to … if you have a good idea, and you know how to sell it - great, come on over and tell us - let’s build something great! And if we fail, hey, we gave it our best shot - cheers! What else do you have?

    That’s why it’s hard to replicate Silicon valley - from the outside, it just looks like a couple great universities, smart people, & investment funds … but that’s about 30% of it.

  10. jbelkin

    Another note - careful about attributing the success of the London SE in an overall sense without factoring in the accounting and Sarbanes Oxney regulations here in the US that chased some companies away to the more lenient exchanges …

  11. Keith Dsouza

    Wow micheal,

    So many apps at one place, I just would love to switch places with you some day.

    I have used three of the applications listed here allpeers, feeds2.0 and not to say the best front page I have used Netvibes, they have techcrunch by default there and that’s what I like, wherever I open it I can get news from here.

    I am gonna try out the others now.

    Well BTW the darker green is nicer on the eyes now.

    I am getting used to it now.

    Cheers
    Keith

  12. Dimitar Vesselinov

    Who’s afraid of the New Europe?
    How off-shoring and tax competition will change the
    economic and political landscape of Europe
    http://www.thersa.org/audio/
    http://www.thersa.org/events/d.....entID=1853

  13. Mark Sylvester

    Michael, when I heard that you were not going to be at Syndicate (while listening to you on Gilmore Gang), I thought you just might be at Innovate - and yep, you were. You and I met at PCForum, we created the onsite network for the attendees. We created one for Guidewire to use for Innovate as well. The network really helped attendees get to know one another better in advance of the conference. I noticed that you had been added to the network, but had never actually signed in to use it.

    These types of tech conferences are so important for each of the consituate audiences. We appreciate being a part of helping startups make connections that they might have a hard time doing using more traditional methods. This conference is just getting off the ground, but we have high hopes for what Chris and Mike are doing and look forward to supporting them for many years.

    Mark

  14. Dennis Howlett

    It’s difficult for EU companies to get attention in the US, especially when there is so much visible action going on in the Valley. I guess it’s just as hard there but in a different way. So it was really good to see Michael at this event - hands across the sea and all that - and providing a second ’showcase’ for some of the products, ideas and services on view. Don’t be a stranger!

  15. Frank Cefalu

    you were so drunk in that video lol

  16. Ari Mir

    For a country claiming (more like wanting) to be the next Silicon Valley, France’s existing infrastructure is anything but entrepreneur friendly.

    In regards to clicmobile…

    “Our patent is protecting the unique link between (1) a user profile, (2) its geo-location and (3) his social network.”

    I am tired of “patent trolls.” I am not calling clicmobile a patent troll, but there is no need to patent an obvious characteristic of the Symantec Web within the context of mobile devices.

    Michael,

    They claim to have an application called “buddy finder.” But after some digging I noticed they are using WAP, i-mode and IP addresses to detect geo-location. From what I know about those technologies, one can only use them to detect a region, such as Beverly Hills, and not actually “Michael is around the corner.”

    In the demo you viewed, were you able to test the “buddy finder” and if so can you please provide some more details in this thread or shoot me an email. Thanks.

  17. Jean-Marc

    For a conference title Innovate, it depresses me to notice that only three of the products you mentioned (readspeaker, digitslide, and clicmobile) were unique concepts. The rest of them seem to either be a rehash of an existing product or an idea without much entrepreneurial potential (a bittorent client instead a browser with a marginal user base? who would invest in that?).
    Ouch, that came off a little harsh :) Point is though, I haven’t noticed a product that’s made me think “I wish I had though of that” or a genuinely new and useful service in a while.
    Does anyone else mirror my thoughts?

  18. RBA

    Jean-Marc,

    You don’t need a “I havent’ thought of that” idea to launch a successful company. Of course it helps if the idea is novel, and most important, *if it solves a problem*, but many successful companies - or perhaps I should say *most* successful companies - became successful based on execution, not for launching a novel idea. In fact, many novel ideas may fail for not launching at the right time. There are countless examples of all of this. Think CoolTalk vs Skype for example. Others simply execute better than those who came first. Windows anyone?

    “I feel your pain” but more often than not, it is the execution, not the idea. You may have read this before: a great idea poorly executed will get nowhere, but an average idea greatly executed will become a success.

    That’s not to endorse whatever companies were mentioned here as having a greater (or smaller) chance of success than others. Time will tell. Just don’t disregard a company simply because you’ve seen it done before.

  19. Jean-Marc

    Very good rebuttal RBA. I can totally see your point of view, but I’m still not sure it’s as applicable in the web startup world then it is in the rest of the business world (even in the software market).
    The problem is that some of these services dwarf the industry leaders in terms of features, but many (myself included) don’t want to go through the hastle of migrating our accounts/loosing our favorites/learning a new program if the current one does the job well enough. I think vPod stands out for it’s advertisement features (and that might be enough to attract the heavy hitters like cable companies), but it’ll take a lot of content and marketing to de-entrench youtube. When I think of the talent that went into making that product I just can’t help but think what kind of amazing unique stuff they could have brought us, hence my cynicysm
    Sorry about the spelling, I just wolk up and haven’t had my morning coffee yet :P

  20. Michael Arrington

    My two cents (Euro cents, that is :-) ) on the RBA/Jean-Marc discussion above:

    Being first matters, but only if there is a network effect involved that can give you a real barrier to entry. Del.icio.us is a perfect example, because it was the first but not even close to the best implementation of social bookmarking, and no one could touch it who came later. Other sites don’t have this advantage and newer, better sites can easily beat them.

    I don’t know if YouTube is in the first category or the second. They certainly have brand awareness and some network effect at least. But they are also burning through tremendous amounts of cash while competitors are springing up all over the place. The recent success of Photobucket with videos (they are seeing video uploads at the same rate as youtube after just a few weeks live) shows that they may not be as entrenched as we thought. I really like what vpod is doing and I think they have a real shot at success.

  21. Jean-Marc

    Totally agree with Michael on the cash issue though. It seems like Youtube doesn’t really have the same ability to generate revenue the way vpod does, and that may end up being the deciding factor a few months down the road when youtube ends up spending all its money on 200tb bandwidth bills

  22. Peter Cooper

    I agree with your first point, but the second and third points really only apply to continental Europe. It’s very easy to set up a limited company in the United Kingdom (you can do it all yourself if you want), and the taxes in the United Kingdom are low (compared to, say, France, Germany, or the Scandinavian countries). This is one reason why my company(ies) is based in the UK and not the US, and I’m not even in London, but 200 miles north.. and it works great that way :)

    I’d argue that another point to add to the list is that there’s a major cultural angle. Europeans, more so than Americans, tend to be reserved and more risk averse. In my own case, I’m quite ‘paranoid with money’ (quoting my investors here!) but proud of that fact. That sort of attitude just doesn’t tend to work in the Valley, but I think it works for me, and after coming through the dot com crash I think the ’37signals approach’ is the best one these days.

  23. Blaze

    There’s some really interesting companies in hear. Great to see what they are doing in europe. I think europeans are incredibly creative.

  24. Roy Lindemann

    Hi Michael,

    Thanks for writing about us. ReadSpeaker is not originally Spanish as it was founded in Sweden and has market presence in most European countries as well as in Japan.

  25. Niclas Bergstrom

    Hi,

    ReadSpeaker is actually also available in North America. We already have our first customers in the US.

  26. Vil

    I’ve tried many AJAX products like NetVibes.
    But their user experiences do not make me feel good.