New Yahoo Maps Shows Power of Flash
Michael Arrington
79 comments »
An all new Yahoo Maps launches tonight at 9 pm PST.
I spoke with Paul Levine, the General Manager of Local, Jeremy Kreitler, a Senior Product Manager of Maps and Local, and Diana Vincent, a PR Manager, earlier today about Yahoo Maps.
Unlike Google and Microsoft maps, Yahoo has chosen to use Flash over AJAX in building its new service, and they’ve added new features that are not found anywhere else. They’ve also done some things to reduce the hassle of creating, sharing and printing maps online.
It’s built with on the new MacroMedia Flex platform for flash, something we’ve been hearing a lot about lately.
Key Features
Because Yahoo Maps is a flash application, it avoids the need for page refreshes changes are made to the page. A simple drag and drop module on the top right lets users move around easily (even easier than the great Google drag method). There are multiple ways to zoom into and out of a map, including using the scroll wheel on the mouse, or the page up/down buttons on the keyboard. The arrow keyboard keys also allow for scrolling off-screen to new areas.
There is excellent integration wth Yahoo Local businesses. Once a map is pulled up, a quick search, such as “pizza” pulls up all local restaurants. A click shows more information, and options to add it to the driving directions itinerary.
And this is cool - they allow multipoint directions, something Google and Microsoft don’t have.. add as many stops as you need, in the order you want, and Yahoo Maps will calculate driving directions for the whole trip. This could be really useful when house hunting, for instance. Simply add all of the addresses and get an itinerary.
And as you edit the map by moving, adding things, etc., the URL in the browser bar self updates so that it can be copied and pasted at any time. This is something that really bugs me about Google Maps - the need to click a link to get a permanent URL. Yahoo’s solved that with some cool javascript coding.
Because Yahoo Maps is built on Flash, the “back button” on the browser still works (a problem with AJAX applications). At any time you can back up into older maps and the URL also rewinds.
Yahoo Maps requires the installation of Flash 7 or greater. 90% of U.S. and European computers already have it installed.
Developer API
Yahoo has two flavors of APIs for developers. The syndication API is a simple way of bringing Yahoo Maps into a website in either Flash of AJAX. They’ve also launched a richer Building Blocks API for maximum flexibility.
That’s a really awesome service, I’m very impressed by the layout and the interface of the site - also very impressive that when you load the site it goes directly to the map of your location - the flash app for maps is now sure to become a tool that is more widely used by other services, hopefully from the likes of Google, MSN, etc.
http://maps.google.com/ powns this site. Grab the map and move it around…Google moves smoothly on a P4 1800, this thing moves in jerks with a 2-5 second refresh.
This is awesome. I don’t care what technology they are using, but this is just awesome.
Once again, Yahoo is more caught up in showing off their technology(see Yahoo Mail Beta) rather than improving and innovating in the realm of the user experience.
I agree with post #3(Chris), the Google Maps interface is much more intuitive, and it runs as smooth as butter on both my 2.0 GHz Celeron laptop, as well as my Powerbook. Not only is the Ymaps interface less intuitive than Gmaps, but as someone else pointed out, the map doesn’t refresh nearly as well as Google’s service.
I’m beginning to think the majority of Googles PhDs are in their user experience departments, and not so much on the technology side.
Nice job. I havn’t had any speed problems. Google Maps is cool and all, but what a rediculous interface. How anyone is expected to know what to do in that mess is beyond me. Kudo’s to Yahoo for a killer UI. Google should have fixed theirs months ago.
I agree with others, was a dog for me with jerky movement, interface isn’t as intuitive as Google, and not as nice a Google with their satellite views. Maps don’t seem as detailed either, it didn’t even have the name of my street list, never have seen that not listed before. Thumbs down so far.
I did not notice any speed issues at all. Quite the opposite in fact. It could be massive traffic, although you’d expect yahoo to be ready for that.
I am absolutely in love with the widget in the top right corner.
Yahoo is utilizing relevant content with this site – stepping into the ultimate consumer game far more efficiently than Google. The bundling of inherently useful info like ATM locations is a needed first step - we can just imagine where it will go…kudos to Yahoo for giving it a shot and not resting on their aerial photo laurels.
It is nice, but I don’t think that anyone is going to move from Google Maps to Yahoo Maps.
Ditto with the jerkyness, but kudos to the interface. Can’t wait to play around a bit more
I think the Yahoo Map is lot better than Google Map. Dragging is smoother and you don’t see the empty squares trying to catch up. Google was trying to prove a point by not using Flash, but does it really matter as long as the users get what they want. BTW, Google uses a Flash for Google Video. Here’s my take on Yahoo map: http://chunnibabu.blogspot.com/
As usual Europe doesn’t make it onto the beta… so can’t really provide qualitative feedback although liked the live traffic status and agree with the jerky nature of the map load.
Strangely entering “http://maps.yahoo.co.uk/beta/” redirects you to “Yahoo! Deutschland” which seems a bit bizarre ….
Looking forward to more being added.
Does anyone know how Yahoo! did the URL-changing in the browser as you move about? It’s a very clever bit of JavaScript, I’d love to know how they did it.
interesting to read that flash 7 penetration is over 90% in europe considering that maps.yahoo.com/beta doesn’t even know europe exists… big thumb down for yahoo
Please, please, please, Yahoo, don’t lose the wi-fi finder. That is why I use Yahoo maps not Google maps.
finially waypoints!
this is now the best map app on the web.
Is comment #28 right or no?
If it’s Flash instead of Javascript that would be really too bad. I was pretty excited to move Wireless Ink’s new mapping of mobile communities [ http://www.winksite.com/site/d.....ns_map.cfm ] to Yahoo from Google (as we get the heck off Cold Fusion in the next month or two).
This is an improvement over both Google and Microsoft. It does run a little slowly but hopefully that can be addressed. Sending to phone and email is HUGE. I can’t believe it’s taken this long for someone to do this.
I worry about Google. Whereas most of their stuff was built with that “20%” of time they get to work on other things I’m not convinced that their devs want to continue building things. They work on something cool and then want to move onto something else. Google is just too slow when it comes to revving their products and they are suffering as a result.
Hey # 28!
The app was built in flash, but Yahoo! has provided a javascript API to manipulate the flash map. Developers can also use the Flash or Flex components directly in Flash or Flex applications. There’s even an AJAX API if you don’t want to use flash at all. Check it out at http://developer.yahoo.net/maps/
I think i’ve made the switch to Yahoo maps. It saved me a lot of time this morning because he traffic can be included on the map instantly. I used the traffic feature to find there was an accident on 101 North in Menlo Park.
Also, it seems to use less of my laptop’s CPU than google maps.. whenever I use google maps, my laptop fan goes to high speed, and sometimes kills the machine as i drag the maps around. I’m happy to hear the fan is running normal speed after dragging around on yahoo maps a bit.
I love the back button capability and that the url changes as you use the map.
I’ve been disappointed with Yahoo recently. They’re consistently later with their releases compared to Google and MSN, and their sites aren’t really that good. The new Y! Maps absolutely sucks. As others have said, moving around is slow. So, again, they’re a year later than everybody else and their site is still the worst of the three.
Interesting, but the Flash requirement means it’s useless to 99% of the mobile devices out there (PDAs, Smartphones, etc.), which is where I do most of my map lookups, etc.
I rarely get lost and need a map or directions when I’m at home in front of my computer!
#39. My point exactly. Which explain why I’m soooo unexcited about either Google Maps or Yahoo Maps and why I had no problem shelling out $$$$ for Microsoft Streets….
Great application if you have access to a PC, however useless if your using a PDA or Mobile phone. I would say that this is gonna be useful to business travellers. But in reality most people know whats in their local area. Maybe thats just my view. However, it works well and it runs quickly. I hope they intend to extend this service to the UK not just the USA.
It isn’t working in FF for me while every other site I’ve been to works fine, i.e. I have the flash plugin installed, now what? It just sits there with a blank page from the Maps Home page.
I hope I get a response to this cause I won’t be back, too long….
Anybody else notice that you can drag the numbered locations from the bottom left section (ATMs, restaurants…) to the directions fields?
Rad.
regarding the comments about Flash for mobile devices.. there has been a Flash light version for a while, and it comes standard installed on most mobile phones in Japan for the past couple of years. Will likely make it into the US phones one of these years.
http://www.macromedia.com/software/flashlite/
And don’t forget, Google Maps consistently gives awful directions. It constantly routes me around highways and results in extremely long trips. Thankfully, I was suspicious and went to yahoo maps!
Actually, AJAX history problems (not working BACK button) have been finally solved. Please, look at:
http://codinginparadise.org/pr.....l_history/
Google could use that - it’s been release under BSD type licence.
There is another small company that made something even better - not only their client is based on flash but the map itself is pure flash based vector map.
The site is:
http://www.abmaps.com
And as i know this site exist at least one year.
EASA INDO USA.CO.LTD. NEW YEARS WELLCOME:2006 HAPPY NEW YEARS,HI,HELLO SIR,MR.BILLGATES MASTER SAHEB, HAVE GOOD YEARS,PROGRESS PRESIDENT CHAIRMAN.MR.BILLGATES(CHAIRMAN.MR.EAJAZSHAIKH INDIAN) SUPER PROJECTS OPREATION (MISSION RAINBOW AIRLINES&AIRFLYLIGHTS USA&UK .CO.LTD.VICTORY OPENION OPREATION DATE:01/01/2006.UNITED GOVTS SPEED BUSINESS&FORWARDS FAST LIFE TAKE&GIVE.WE ARE EASA INDO USA.CO.LTD.TECHNOLOGY MANAGMENTS OFFICESERS STAFS NAMES.MR.BILLGATES.MR.EAJAZSHAIKH.MR.BMWCO.BOSS.MR.MERCESDES CO.BOSS.PRESIDENT USA MR.BUSH.PRESIDENT UK MR.TONYBLAIR.GROUP OF OTHERS OFFICESERS&DIRECTERS UNDER THAT ARE CO.EASA INDO USA LTD.WE ARE GROUP WARKING MISSION RAINBOW AIRFLYLIGHTS VICTORY OPREATION USA&UK GOVTS SAFETY PASSENGERS USSING NEW AIRLINES RAINBOW. OK SIR,BILLGATES,MR.EAJAZSHAIKH:MY USA VISA DOCUMENTS&FILES SUBMITE DELHI USA EMBASSY BUT SIR,YOU ARE HALP ME&PLEASE CONTACT NEW DELHI USA EMBASSY HURRY UP DEAR SIR,BILLGATES,MR.EAJAZ STUDENTS:I WILL COME USA&UK BUT VISA PROPOSALY EMBASSY OF AMERICA.EAJAZ:MY ECONOMICAL PROBLEMS YOU ARE SHORT OUT ,EAJAZ:ME I HAVE NOT GIVE ENTER FEES RED COST:RS.4400+2200+298/NOT SUBMMIET SMALL PROBLEM ME ,I HAVE FILES IMP CASE USA VISA LONG WAITTING BUT WAIT NOT FUTCHERS CARRERS&PROGRESS EMERGENCY CASE MR.EAJAZ SHAIKH TAKE&GIVE USA VISA FILES FROM.GUJARAT (CITY VALSAD,VILLAGE.ATUL,396020)INDIA. MR.BILLGATES:MR.BISMILLAH M.SHAIKH HIS ELDER SON MR.EAJAZ FOR EAJU SHAIKH.HE WAS WARKED SERVIES CYANAMID USA&INDIA CO.LTD.SERVIESED EXP:25YEARS AGO BEFORE PASSED TIME.BUT MR.B.M.SHAIKH DEATH TOTALY APSSENT SHAIKH FAMILY BIG LOSE ELDER SON MR.EAJAZ SHAIKH&TREAGEDY SO&SO NOW THAT ARE DENGERS TIME COOL BRAIN USE HE HAVE EAJAZ USE SMART ACTIVITY BRAIN SUPER SPEED WARKING DO TECHNOLOGY EXPORT INDIA&IMPORT USA BY POST MAIL TAKE&GIVE CATCHING MAIL,THERE ARE MR.BILLGATES HOUSE& USA PRESIDENT MR.BUSH HOUSE GOOD INFORMATION BY POST MAIL FROM TO.MR.EAJAZSHAIKH INDIA. 7ANAND COLONY ATUL.1ST GATE POLTRY,FARM RD.HWY NO.8 CITY.VALSAD. VILLAGE,ATUL &POST PIN:396020/TEL;233530/VALSAD POST TEL;249982/MY KALIYANI SCHOOL ATUL TEL;233247/MR.EAJAZ FOR EAJU SHAIKH TEL;9374047904/POST MASTER TEL;233979/9898446335/02634-263669/ EAJAZ SHAIKH:NEXT INFORMATION NEWS (MR.RIYAZSHAIKH. HE HIS MY BROTHER BUT PROBLEMS NOT GOOD BEHAVE TO.USA CALIFONIYA SKILL VISA LAST 3YARES TOFROM THERE IS USA)PLEASE SIR BILLGATE THEY ARE MR.RIYAZ SHAIKH NOT CONTACT& WITH WIEF SHIRIN SHAIKH BUT HE&SHE SALFISHER I AM SUME THING ANY TIME BEHAVE) OK. DEAR SIR.MR.BILLGATES MASTER SAHEB (DENGER NEWS.RAMEN DESAI USA JAIL FROM GUJARAT ATUL DESAI) CBI-CID ARESTTING USA AIR PORTS.THEY ARE DENGER FAMILY DESAI RAMEN WITH PRAVINABEN DASAI,RITESH DESAI&ANJELIDESAI&RAHULDESAI) TOTALY NOT GOOD OK. SIR.BILLGATES MASTER SAHEB GOOD BY BY BY.THANK YOU ,YOUR STIDENTS MR.EAJAZSHAIKH INDIAN./////////////////////////////////.
hes yahoo thery gfoodf
It is nice, but Google Maps is better
Hi Rado. Google mabs is very gut and dis is true.
Hej Rado?
B2E2 Indo Royals American co.Ltd. boss of chairman Mr.eajaz shaikh: Hi Hello dear, BMW Royals Germany Co.ltd. boss of chaiman mr.sir. aap ko emails kiya hai or, humesha yek( New Rainbow airbuses USA,UK,GERMANY, Companies Limited, humesha humari new companies ka groups, aage developments kare yeh humari mahenat hai or, hum log publics passengers ko kucch new safety or, time pass ke liye humari mahenat humesha rahegi yeh, Mercedes benz Germany co.ltd. bhi humari companies mai groups mai hai, others, Mr.billgates master sir, or mai (Mr.eajaz shaikh indian) mr.Bush sir, mr.Tonyblair sir, mr.Mittal lakshmi sir, or, miss.melinda gates aunti, or, cyanamid usa&uk co.ltd. others, new business mans humari companies mai members hoge or, humara companies groups develops or progress karega or yeh hi humari victory hai. ok, yes. BMW Royals Germany Co.Ltd. Mr.Boss sir thank you very much.[ Mr.Eajazshaikh ka india se emails,To. BMW Royals Germany Co.ltd. Dear Mr.Boss sir.]
Now, convince Zvents to take that Google Map off of their page and put a Yahoo one (or a Virtual Earth one). Hint: they won’t do it. Why? For two reasons:
1) The Yahoo and Virtual Earth licensing terms keep them from putting the map next to a Google advertising component.
2) There’s a perception that Google will treat companies who stick with all of its components better (maybe by giving a discount in the future, maybe by serving out better ads, maybe, by, alas, making both components better through using attention data!
3) They know that putting Google logos on their site is “cooler” and “more buzz generating” than putting Yahoo or Microsoft logos on their site (and they’d be right, heck, I work for Microsoft and I’m talking about their site).
This is a great article. I am new to your blog and i like what I see. I look forward to your future work.
I’ve taken a quick look at your postings, which are very interesting. Lots of material and ideas! Congrats on being so focused!
The advice given in your blog is fantastic and very complimentary to my site, check it out http://ratesfun.com
The new Yahoo maps really sucks. They made it so flashy that it’s useless for basic tasks like finding locations. I’m switching to Mapquest.