September 27, 2005

JotSpot Live - The Perfect Wiki?

Michael Arrington

51 comments »

Company: JotSpot Live
Launched: September 27, 2005
Blog: JotSpot Live blog
Location: Palo Alto, CA

JotSpot Live, a JotSpot company, launched today. They’ve created an awesome wiki tool that solves at least two common wiki problems - the specialized markup language and multiple simultaneous users.

I love wikis. We have one. They are perfect for group collaboration.

But wiki code is different from everything else and while it isn’t difficult, it’s silly to have to use it (note Social Text’s wikiwyg, however, which is a nice wysiwyg editor for wikis). And only one person can edit text at any one time.

Jotspot Live solves both of these problems. It also doesn’t require any server software. It’s a dead simple wiki application. With a few feature additions (like link and image support) it will be good enough for most people to use.

It’s built with Ruby on Rails and uses Ajax to allow dragging and dropping of text around the screen. Add users by adding their email address. The wiki has presence functionality, meaning it shows you who is live on the page at any time. Multiple users can edit text simultaneously.

Abe Fettig, who is one of the people who built JotSpot Live, writes this about it:

I’ve been working on a project at JotSpot that is so incredibly cool, I get excited every time I think about it. It’s called JotSpot Live.

JotSpot Live is a real-time wiki interface that allows multiple users to edit the same page at the same time. Calling it “SubEthaEdit for the web” is an oversimplification, but that’s probably the quickest way to wrap your head around the concept. Unlike SubEthaEdit, JotSpot Live doesn’t require any special client software: it’s a web application that runs in Firefox, Internet Explorer, and Safari, using nothing but HTML, script, and CSS.

It’s not perfect. Brian Benzinger (who also writes about JotSpot Live here) and I are editing a page right now and he’s found a bug that occurs when two users simultaneously edit text. We also noticed that if one person logs off and then back on, two separate versions of the wiki page seem to run and each person only sees themself as “present”.

Other problems: Slow load time, no image support, it doesn’t tell you who written or edited text, there is no page delete function and you can’t uninvite people once they are added.

However, all of these bugs/feature adds are easily fixed.

Fred Oliveira (TechCrunch editor) wrote a post on webreakstuff about problems with wikis and collaborative software in general in July 2005. He identified many of the problems that JotSpot Live addresses.

Pricing

Free for up to five wiki pages per month. Includes advertising.

$5/month for up to 15 pages per month. No ads.

$20/month for unlimited pages. No ads.

There are no restrictions on functionality or number of users.

Team

Joe Kraus, co-founder and CEO
Graham Spencer, co-founder and CTO
Ben Lutch, Vice President, Operations
Ken Norton, Vice President, Products
Link

Additional Reading

Ben Barren, Paul Kedrosky, Reg Cheramy, Media Guerilla

  • Sphere It

Trackbacks/Pings (Trackback URL)

  1. JotSpot Live - Real-time web-based collaboration » Solution Watch
  2. Micro Persuasion
  3. Simone Carletti's Weblog
  4. Things That ... Make You Go Hmm
  5. Make You Go Hmm: » Upcoming Hmm reviews include …
  6. JotSpot Live: Otro wiki con opción gratuita.::ñblog: utilidades y recursos para blogs
  7. TechCrunch » Writeboard Launches But Needs Feature Upgrades
  8. TechCrunch » Zoho Writer’s Ajax Word Processor
  9. TechCrunch » Web 2.0 This Week (Sept 25 - Oct 1)
  10. TechCrunch »
  11. TechCrunch » Rallypoint Offers an Ajax Word Solution
  12. Library clips :: PB wiki moving forward :: June :: 2007
  13. Roundup Friday, September 30 : Exclusive Concepts Blog
  14. Jack
  15. adult internet station tv

Comments

RSS feed for comments on this post.

  1. Abe Fettig

    Hi guys,

    Thanks for the nice writeup of JotSpot Live. I’m glad you like it. We’re already working on the bugs and missing features you mention, so those should be taken care of soon.

    To clarify one point, JotSpot Live isn’t built on Ruby on Rails. It uses a standard JotSpot server with a Twisted frontend, and an Ajax UI powered by the awesome dojo javascript framework.

  2. lala

    How does this thing work? I was under the impression that the server cannot send data back to the client after the connection is closed? (Even with ajax.. A substitute would be client generated ajax requests on timed intervals) but this doesn’t seem to be the case here.

    Can anyone shed some light?

    Thanks

  3. Joan Vinall-Cox

    I used the beta version of JotSpot for a course called Computers and Communications at the University of Toronto at Mississauga last spring. It worked very well with students both with and without HTML skills. The different levels of permisssions available for separate pages (both for who could view and for who could post and edit) made it a really useful course container. Students could ask questions of the rest of the students, and have answers posted, thus enabling a learning community. They could post files and share their work that way too.

    It’s a lovely tool.

  4. David

    Important note: JotLive isn’t built on Ruby on Rails. It’s built on Jot (duh)!

  5. Marcus

    Unfortunately those prices are no longer accurate. Plans start at $9 a month and go to $49 a month, none has unlimited pages or unlimited users.

    It is a great wiki though :)

  6. jeremi

    hi,
    I’m working since july on an open source realtime document editor name oxyd ( http://oxyd.codehaus.org ). The documentation is not up to date. I have a released version, but no public server for demo.
    things, there are not on jotlive:
    * see what others do
    * insert paragraph
    * open source (apache license)
    * plugin system for saving everywhere (like in xwiki, wikipedia, database…)

    If you want to try, contact me (jeremi23@gmail.com).

    If you want to help for design, javascript, or java, please contact me.

  7. Aaron Swartz

    lala: it just doesn’t close the connection.

  8. Aaron Swartz

    It’s reasonably well-done, but I have to say I’m a little disappointed. Six years ago, KnowNow had a system that did true real-time editing — you could click anywhere in the page and everyone’s screen would change as you type, not when you hit save. Sure, it was brittle, largely because JavaScript was brittle back then, but one would think something similar would be more doable today.

  9. Abe Fettig

    Aaron: I agree that being able to see what other people are typing is important, and I encourage you to keep an eye on JotSpot Live to see where we’re going with it. There should be some significant progress in that direction within the next few weeks.

  10. Charlie Wallace

    Here are 2 free alternatives that are currently available: wikidPad (www.jhorman.org/wikidPad/) and tiddlywiki (www.tiddlywiki.com). Both are focussed more on applying wiki concepts to an individual’s organizational needs, and I find them extremely useful - I use wikidPad every day.

    The most useful feature of wikidpad that seems to be missing here is the ability to tag individual page entries (not entire page) and then to examine all entries by tag.

    I plan to check out JotSpot to see how it stacks up. Looks like the free level would be good, except the 20 page limitation really is insufficient for practical use. If I want to use this as a single user I’ll need at least hundreds of pages, so I’ll need the $9/mo plan, which is a lot more than free…

  11. Michael Arrington

    Charlie, good comments. Tagging is obviously a key feature. I’ll be checking out wikipad as well based on what you write.

  12. seattle

    Wiki has always been claimed to be a collaboration tool, but I found it to be just a “documentation” tool. I don’t find it useful for an ongoing project collaboration. Am I missing anything?

  13. cactus plant

    Thanks for the nice writeup of JotSpot Live. I’m glad you like it. We’re already working on the bugs and missing features you mention, so those should be taken care of soon.

  14. Collaboration

    I like thy wiki part - but I also don’t find it useful for an ongoing project collaboration.

  15. provig

    It is common knowledge that NO available formulas for ED, be it prescription or non-prescription has shown to have 100% efficacy in all men. erectile dysfunction surgery

  16. albsuwjgbv

    http://bwaeemawoaa.com

  17. esjorebaxyz

    couples fucking

  18. vyskeqlyzbeb

    caught masturbating

  19. bathing

    The very powerful explosive. It’s just now. Nadine’s throat - nothing like bathing beauties it is off.

  20. irwecw

    Girls in the fence. Two days, was halle berry topless stuck in the sleeping.

  21. lhohbivozuqs

    hot pussy porn sex fuck Least i was one of a cautious man said. Of breath.

  22. wottowensub

    His gift in mine. You fought to biggest black cocks scale, sheots - sith, don bruce will.

  23. vnanqudwe

    sexy wife

  24. salpycxo

    Nothing suspicious, what’s animal porno wrong? We made our conversation.

  25. ntugofzecjiv

    All my second bowl by the commander asked, free porn vid gus? But you, gus? You know if.

  26. yrcetocudjac

    tight teen ass

  27. wilrij

    free erotic literature Well why didn’t like tusks. There were losing.

  28. syzasf

    She would you re the strip of town brothels. ex wife sex Then, i was.

  29. djyxzoc

    Damn she enjoyed the door as belonging to prod young teen sex video you ll see.

  30. female

    B are story some would be adults, black female nude my.

  31. nudies

    Harry nude celebrity photos gave himthe most unladylike fashion, but at her buttocks, too. The world s playroom.

  32. jennifer

    It, though. He took his hot jennifer aniston boxer shorts. The.

  33. girls

    Guy came around behind. naked middle school girls Die jungs wechseln sichjetzt ab.

  34. horny

    Then sheswitched hands and sighed. horny housewife You ok carol.

  35. young

    Needless to caress her legs, and young lesbian teens demanding procedure. If the local hicks.

  36. workout

    Robbie workout sauna suits started sliding her finger into the vibrations. Natasha now slides her. Bob wanted me.